Superheated magma may explain why similar volcanoes erupt in very different ways

Superheated magma may explain why similar volcanoes erupt in very different ways Robert Egan Associate Editor Scientists have shed light on a thermal process in magma that may help explain why similar volcanic systems can produce very different eruptive behaviors. An international team, led by The University of Manchester, studied magma from the 2021 Tajogaite eruption on La Palma, Spain, and found that "superheating"—a state in which magma is heated above the temperature at which crystals are stable—can strongly delay the formation of crystals as magma rises towards Earth's surface. Published in Nature Communications, the study shows that high temperatures can dissolve tiny pre-existing crystal "seeds" that normally help new crystals begin to form. Superheating also changes the internal structure of the magma, making it more uniform, and less able to support the formation of new crystals. This influences how quickly magma rises and how easily volcanic gases can escape, both of which play an important role in determining how explosive the eruption will be. The findings help address a long-standing scientific debate about how a magma's thermal history influences crystallization processes before and during eruptions. Lead author, Dr. Barbara Bonechi, Research Associate at The University of Manchester, said, "The history of crystal and bubble growth can dramatically control how a magma erupts. In particular, as more crystals grow, they eventually have a dramatic effect on magma viscosity. Until now, we did not fully understand the dynamics of crystal growth for magmas that received an injection of superheat just before ascent. But using our exciting and newly developed X-ray transparent pressure vessel combined with synchrotron X-ray microtomography, we can actually observe these processes 'in situ.'" The researchers recreated volcanic conditions in the laboratory using magma from the Tajogaite eruption, which may have experienced some degree of superheating prior to eruption and during ascent. Using synchrotron X-ray microtomography at Diamond Light Source, where crystallization could be observed in real time, alongside complementary ex-situ experiments in Prague that allowed longer observation times, the team were able to track crystallization processes under controlled conditions of high temperature and pressure. They found that magma that had not been superheated began crystallizing within around 20 minutes. In contrast, magma exposed to strong superheating delayed crystal formation for more than eight hours. The researchers then incorporated the experimentally measured nucleation delays into numerical models of magma ascent—simulations that predict how magma moves and evolves as it rises through Earth's crust. The models showed that long crystallization delays can allow magma to rise rapidly while remaining relatively fluid, potentially promoting dramatic lava fountaining behavior. In contrast, magma that crystallizes earlier becomes more viscous and ascends more slowly, allowing more time for gases to escape and favoring more gentle, effusive behavior. The researchers say the findings could improve how scientists interpret volcanic monitoring signals and forecast eruption behavior. Co-author, Dr. Margherita Polacci, Senior Lecturer in Volcanology at The University of Manchester, said, "Current volcanic hazard models typically focus on magma chemistry, gas content and pressure changes. This work suggests that pre-eruptive thermal history and crystallization kinetics may also play an important role in controlling magma ascent and eruptive behavior, with implications for volcanic hazard assessment." Publication details Superheating in mafic magmas controls clinopyroxene nucleation delay and magma ascent dynamics, Nature Communications (2026). DOI: 10.1038/s41467-026-73352-1 Journal information: Nature Communications Provided by University of Manchester