Home Health Elderly man murdered wife in their Canberra home, judge finds
Health

Elderly man murdered wife in their Canberra home, judge finds

Elderly man murdered wife in their Canberra home, judge finds
Key Points

He was charged with murder, but was earlier this year found unfit to plead to the charge, requiring ACT Supreme Court Justice Andrew Muller to hold a special hearing of the case. Justice Muller has now determined Uhle murdered his wife. "It is beyond reasonable doubt that Uhle stabbed his wife repeatedly with a knife, resulting in her death," his reasons for the decision said.

He was charged with murder, but was earlier this year found unfit to plead to the charge, requiring ACT Supreme Court Justice Andrew Muller to hold a special hearing of the case. Justice Muller has now determined Uhle murdered his wife. "It is beyond reasonable doubt that Uhle stabbed his wife repeatedly with a knife, resulting in her death," his reasons for the decision said. He also determined Uhle's actions were voluntary. "His was voluntary in the sense that his movements were controlled and administered repeatedly; he was conscious and, to the extent his consciousness was impaired, it was not impaired so as to deprive him of the will to act," Justice Muller noted in his decision. "I am satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that Mr Uhle engaged in the conduct required for the offence charged on the indictment." At the time of the murder, the couple had been in a relationship for about 60 years. In the months leading up to the murder, his family noted Uhle had experienced episodes of confusion and memory loss which continued to deteriorate. Uhle has been in custody since the day of the murder. As noted by Justice Muller, the prosecution argues the only suitable way forward is an order remanding Uhle in custody for immediate review by the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal (ACAT) under mental health legislation. "In making that submission, the prosecution accepts detention in a correctional facility should be a last resort; but no other option presents itself at the present time," Justice Muller said. Justice Muller said he would allow the parties in the case to explore the issue further, and whether that could include releasing Uhle to facilitate an ACAT assessment for the purpose of making a mental health order. [Image text:] S0ESEAI OPERA 3.5 SCUE RESS HXSETH PERA ESC ROGRESS EARCH OPERAT UEX
Canberra (LOCATION) Supreme Court (ORG) Andrew Muller (PERSON) Muller (PERSON) Uhle (PERSON) the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal (ORG) ACAT (ORG)
Originally published by ABC Australia Read original →