Health
Killer jailed for strangling lover to death whines he should be freed - despite saying he's the 'victim'
Key Points
Killer jailed for strangling lover to death whines he should be freed - despite saying he's the 'victim' EXCLUSIVE: John Mearns murdered Pauline Smith after she said she wanted to return to her family in 2011 - but he spun of web of lies and tried to shift the blame on her A killer who strangled his lover to death after a row over beans on toast has complained he should be freed - despite experts saying he thinks he's the "victim". Mum-of-two Pauline Smith, 54, was killed in her flat by John...
Killer jailed for strangling lover to death whines he should be freed - despite saying he's the 'victim'
EXCLUSIVE: John Mearns murdered Pauline Smith after she said she wanted to return to her family in 2011 - but he spun of web of lies and tried to shift the blame on her
A killer who strangled his lover to death after a row over beans on toast has complained he should be freed - despite experts saying he thinks he's the "victim".
Mum-of-two Pauline Smith, 54, was killed in her flat by John Mearns, who she had left her husband for, in 2011. Days before her death in St Ives, Cambs, she said she wanted to return to her family.
Mearns, 68, told a 999 operator she was supposed to cook him dinner "but all I got was beans on toast", Cambridge Crown Court heard. He received a life sentence and was told he would serve a minimum of 14 years before being eligible for parole.
He has now complained that a Parole Board panel "irrationally" blocked his release from jail. But dismissing Mearns' appeal for freedom, Stephen Dawson, on behalf of the Parole Board, said: "The panel took the view that [Mearns] accepted responsibility for taking the life of the victim, although this acceptance was qualified and [Mearns] did not accept that he committed the offence of murder.
"The panel also noted that [Mearns] remained of the view that he was the victim and blamed others for the outcome of the index offence." Mearn's trial was told he called an ambulance to Mrs Smith’s home in Gainsborough Drive on October 27 to report he had been stabbed and feared his partner was dead.
Mearns later changed his story, admitting he had stabbed himself. But he still claimed he had unwittingly caused her death while trying to restrain her and prevent her from attacking him. His trial was told he pushed down so hard on his lover's throat that it fractured her voice box and caused bleeding around her eyes.
Mrs Smith had wanted to return to her family, but Mearns became "possessive, jealous and controlling", it was claimed. He grew violent when he feared their "on–off relationship" was over.
His murder trial heard a recording of a 999 call that Mearns made the morning after Mrs Smith's death, in which he said she was supposed to have cooked him dinner, but "all I got was beans on toast". He also claimed that she attacked him with a knife.
"I hope she's not dead. She was really nasty towards me," he said. "I just don't know why she was like that. I think she has got a split personality. I tried to stop her sticking the knife in me and I don't know, I must have, I must have. I tried. I obviously tried to get her to stop trying to stab me."
Mearns was described as a self–obsessed liar who changed his story as he "struggled to establish a defence for himself". He originally claimed he was protecting himself when Mrs Smith "lashed out", then told police he did not mean to kill her.
In sentencing Mearns, Judge Anthony Bate said: “There was no evidence of planning or premeditation. The surprise and speed of the assault meant Pauline had no opportunity to defend herself before she was overpowered.
"You knelt on Pauline’s stomach as she lay on the bed and applied sustained manual pressure to her neck. By then, you had formed the intent to kill her.” He added: “In the aftermath of the killing you showed yourself to be a fluent and resourceful liar.”
Judge Bate said the impact of Mrs Smith’s death on her children was “profound”. He said: “Her children have lost the support of their mother… The pain of her loss is profound.”
After the sentence Det Chief Insp George Barr, who led the investigation, said: “Mearns has taken a mother from her children and this is something they, and their family, will have to live with for the rest of their lives. I hope today’s sentence brings them some comfort knowing that justice has been done.”
John Mearns (PERSON)
Pauline Smith (PERSON)
St Ives (LOCATION)
Cambs (PERSON)
Mearns (PERSON)
Cambridge Crown Court (ORG)
Parole Board (ORG)
Stephen Dawson (PERSON)
the Parole Board (ORG)
Mearn (PERSON)
Mrs Smith’s (PERSON)
Gainsborough Drive (LOCATION)
Mrs Smith (PERSON)
Mrs Smith's (PERSON)
Anthony Bate (PERSON)