Health
Conditions imposed on surgeon years after Qld grandmother's death
Key Points
Surgeon Stefaan De Clercq to be mentored three years after death of Joanne Downie In short: The Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency (AHPRA) has confirmed that conditions have been placed on the medical registration of doctor Stefaan De Clercq. Bundaberg grandmother Joanne Downie died in October 2023 after a gastric bypass and gall bladder surgery.
Surgeon Stefaan De Clercq to be mentored three years after death of Joanne Downie
In short:
The Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency (AHPRA) has confirmed that conditions have been placed on the medical registration of doctor Stefaan De Clercq.
Bundaberg grandmother Joanne Downie died in October 2023 after a gastric bypass and gall bladder surgery.
What's next?
Ms Downie's family is calling for an improved complaints process after the drawn-out investigation.
Conditions have been imposed on a bariatric surgeon nearly three years after one of his patients died from complications in a Queensland regional hospital.
The Medical Board of Australia (MBA) has delivered their findings after an investigation into the death of Bundaberg grandmother Joanne Downie following complications from an elective gastric bypass and gall bladder surgery in October 2023.
The Queensland coroner found her death was caused by a rupture of the small bowel, peritonitis with sepsis, laparoscopic gastric bypass surgery, and a hiatus hernia repair.
Her family lodged a complaint about the surgeon, Stefaan De Clercq, with the Office of the Health Ombudsman in December 2023, which was referred to the Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency (AHPRA) for investigation.
A spokesperson for AHPRA confirmed the MBA had imposed conditions on Dr De Clercq's registration, which related to clinical care and the use of combined procedures that may expose patients to additional risks.
"Conditions are imposed on a practitioner's registration to ensure the public is protected while a practitioner continues to work," the spokesperson said.
'Disappointing' conclusion on anniversary
Ms Downie's daughter, Emily Clarke, said she was "disappointed" the matter was only finalised in September, after being told it would take between six to 12 months.
"It's been three years since Mum died … for that to sort of accumulate on the anniversary of her death was really hard," she said.
The 60-year-old underwent the combined surgery at the Friendly Society Private Hospital on October 16, 2023. After suffering from severe pain and drowsiness, a corrective surgery was performed five days later.
Ms Downie was then transferred to the Bundaberg Hospital intensive care unit, where she underwent a third operation but died the following day.
The ABC has contacted Dr De Clercq for comment.
Originally from Belgium, Dr De Clercq was appointed the director of surgery at Gladstone Hospital from October 2017 until he moved to Bundaberg's Friendly Society Private Hospital in April 2020.
The ABC understands he departed the private hospital on November 13, 2023, just two weeks after Ms Downie's death.
Dr De Clercq's online profiles show he relocated to Victoria and was credited at the Mulgrave Private Hospital earlier this year, but a spokesperson for the hospital said he never practised there.
Mentoring and audit conditions
The AHPRA spokesperson said compliance with conditions was monitored closely, and any breach could result in further regulatory action by the Board to ensure public safety.
"These conditions include that Dr De Clercq must be mentored by an approved mentor for a minimum of 10 sessions, on a monthly basis, with each session being of one hour in duration," said the spokesperson.
Dr De Clercq must also undergo an audit of his practice with a focus on patient selection and clinical decision-making in complex presentations and the use of combined procedures in patients with elevated risk profiles.
Ms Downie's daughter, Emily Clarke, said the ruling has left her with more questions than answers.
"Who is an appropriate mentor?" she said.
"Can your friend just be your mentor or does it need to be something more formal than that?"
The AHPRA spokesperson said the mentor would be nominated by Dr De Clercq and must be a registered practitioner.
"AHPRA or the relevant National Board assesses whether the nominated mentor satisfies the requirements of the conditions," they said.
"This assessment will include the nominee's own regulatory history and whether they have specific qualifications or experience to address the specific concerns raised.
"The mentor must declare they are not in a close collegiate, family, social or financial relationship with the practitioner."
Calls to improve complaints system
Ms Clarke said she was disappointed with the communication from AHPRA.
"Being able to ask questions about the process and being told that the process is now closed and the only way to get more information is to do another complaint is really difficult to hear," she said.
"I think there's a lot of room for improvement there and a lot of room for more transparency as well.
"Some of the challenges were definitely the timeframes that we were given and a few times we were told, 'Oh, we'll have an update for you soon.'
"A lot of the time I had to keep chasing that update, but it was never anything meaningful."
Qld (LOCATION)
Stefaan De Clercq (PERSON)
Joanne Downie (PERSON)
The Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency (ORG)
AHPRA (ORG)
Bundaberg (LOCATION)
Ms Downie's (PERSON)
Queensland (LOCATION)
The Medical Board of Australia (ORG)
the Office of the Health Ombudsman (ORG)
Dr De Clercq's (PERSON)
Emily Clarke (PERSON)
Mum (PERSON)
the Friendly Society Private Hospital (ORG)
Ms Downie (PERSON)