LONDON — Andy Burnham wants to sound out options with the EU in his quest to ease Brexit. But Brussels is signaling that the U.K. prime minister needs to get his own plan together first.
The PM used a major foreign affairs speech Monday night to slow the timeline of his ambitions for bringing Britain closer to the bloc.
Instead of setting out “different options” for future relations around the time of Friday’s upcoming EU-U.K. summit, as he promised in September, he now wants to first fish for options with European allies.
But that timeline isn’t being welcomed with open arms in Brussels.
A senior EU diplomat with knowledge of the European Commission’s desired process made clear to POLITICO that the first step is for Britain to decide what changes it is considering.
“On the next steps, it should be about the U.K. first assessing its options and then engaging with the EU, rather than the other way around,” said the official, granted condition of anonymity to discuss internal thinking.
Britain’s PM may, however, find more sympathetic ears among member states than in the European Commission.
A second EU diplomat said Burnham’s suggestion that he would sound out Brussels about different options “makes sense,” adding there is a “need to be pragmatic.”
“There are very real mutual benefits to be unlocked,” they said. “Rather than getting lost in abstract debates about the ultimate destination, perhaps the more useful question is where we can make co-operation work better, here and now?”
A third EU diplomat said there could be a “gray area” in which both things are true.
While Britain can’t do “substantial negotiations” with the EU until there’s a “consensus” in the U.K., the diplomat said it would be right for “some level of conversation with Brussels to see what’s sensible” so that realistic options can then be discussed with the British public.
A fourth diplomat agreed the process must first happen in Britain, but expressed an openness to discussing possible options with the U.K. to facilitate the process.
Anand Menon, the director of the UK in a Changing Europe think tank, said a timeline where Brussels wants firmer proposals first should come as no surprise to Britain.
“The EU wants Britain to come to them and say this is the kind of relationship they want,” he said. “They want us to do that with a relationship that’s on offer rather than make up something that they are not willing to give.”
Two U.K. government officials suggested that Burnham will still address future relations with Europe after the summit — but that this would be more limited to the “next steps” for the process.
Later on Tuesday, Burnham seemed to soften his language again, telling Sky News he will consider “whether there are options” to deepen Britain’s relationship with the EU. He said he would set them out alongside a government-wide 10-year plan due later this year.
That would appear to fall short of what Burnham billed back in September, when addressing supporters in his first Labour Party conference speech as leader.
Back then, the U.K. prime minister promised “to lay out to the country what I believe the different options are for Britain’s long-term relationship with our European partners” at some point “around the summit” in Brussels on Friday.
He left a full-blown push to rejoin the EU open as one of the possibilities.
Since then, however, there has been a wave of hesitancy coming from within Burnham’s own Cabinet about the ramifications of reopening the fraught Brexit debate.
British public opinion may have changed greatly since the 2016 referendum, but U.K. politics remains scarred by the rancorous debates it produced.
Burnham used a Lord Mayor’s banquet speech in London on Monday evening to try cool off the timeline of his new approach.
“After the summit, we will initiate a discussion with our EU partners about options for our long-term relationship, recognizing that both Britain and the EU are very different to what they were,” he said.
“This will take time and we will present those options and our assessment of them to inform decisions in the next parliament. At every stage, the British people will be the boss.”
Andrew McDonald contributed reporting.