Business & Finance
Why Home Depot shares are falling despite an earnings beat — and how to proceed
Key Points
Home Depot on Tuesday reported better-than-expected third-quarter results, but subdued guidance into year-end is likely weighing on the stock. We're not spooked by the weakness, believing investors should view it as an opportunity. Revenue in the three months ended Nov. 1 increased 4.9% year over year to $43.4 billion, outpacing the $42.8 billion expected by LSEG.
Home Depot on Tuesday reported better-than-expected third-quarter results, but subdued guidance into year-end is likely weighing on the stock. We're not spooked by the weakness, believing investors should view it as an opportunity. Revenue in the three months ended Nov. 1 increased 4.9% year over year to $43.4 billion, outpacing the $42.8 billion expected by LSEG. Adjusted earnings per share (EPS) increased 3.2% to $3.86, exceeding the LSEG-compiled estimate of $3.74. Same-store sales , or comps, increased 2.2% versus the year-ago period, well ahead of the 1.7% expected, according to FactSet. This also represents the fourth quarter in a row of sequential acceleration. Home Depot also announced Tuesday that CFO Richard McPhail has been named CEO, effective Nov. 23. Ted Decker — who has now returned from a medical leave that began in August — will step down as CEO, but will continue as the chairman of the board. Though the shakeup is a bit of a surprise, McPhail is very well equipped for the role thanks to his 21-year tenure with the company. He's been CFO since 2019. Jordan Broggi will move into the role of executive vice president and CFO. Ann-Marie Campbell, who had been helping lead the company in Decker's absence, will take over as president and COO. Campbell has worked at Home Depot for 41 years, beginning as a store associate. Shares of Home Depot dropped about 2% on Tuesday, to roughly $340 apiece. At their lows of the session, shares traded as down to $334.44, before some buyers stepped in. If not for our trading restrictions, we would've been among those buyers. HD YTD mountain Home Depot's year-to-date stock performance. Bottom line The sluggish U.S. housing market, stemming from elevated borrowing costs, continues to be a problem for Home Depot. But we have no question that Home Depot is executing well and controlling what it can. While the management team did say the current environment is softer than what it expected at the beginning of the year, it also expressed confidence that Home Depot is taking market share. That's exactly what we want to hear, and it helps explain why we're willing to shrug off the company's tepid outlook into year-end, specifically on implied fourth-quarter earnings per share. Plus, the culture at Home Depot is to be conservative with guidance, and a new CEO coming in likely reinforces that inclination. We would be buyers of Tuesday's weakness given the potential for oil to keep trending lower, bringing inflation expectations and bond yields down with it. Should that view pan out, we would expect mortgage rates to retreat and shares of Home Depot to climb higher, as investors anticipate a rebound in the housing market. And with the strong internal execution that Home Depot has demonstrated during these multiyear period of housing malaise, the company is poised to win in this scenario. We therefore reiterate our buy-equivalent 1 rating and $370 price target. Commentary Companywide same-store sales growth of 2.2% was the best quarterly result since we've owned the stock. During the three months ended Nov. 1, a 3% increase in the average ticket price more than offset a 0.5% decline in customer transactions. As for the monthly cadence, comps increased 1.1% in August, 3.8% in September, and 1.8% in October. Within the U.S., same-store sales also increased 2.2%, well ahead of the 1.4% expected, according to FactSet. Month by month, comps rose 1.1% in August, 4.4% in September, and 1.3% in October. The U.S. is by far Home Depot's largest and most important market. It also does business in Canada and Mexico. Home Depot saw "notable strength in repair and remodel categories," McPhail said on the earnings call, adding that 13 of the company's 16 merchandising departments realized positive comp growth in the quarter, and that "online continues to deliver double-digit growth." Campbell added that this represents the sixth consecutive quarter of double-digit comp growth for the online business. William Bastek, the company's EVP of merchandising, called out "tremendous success" in its power merchandise category, which saw double-digit comp growth. This category includes things like power tools and outdoor power equipment like generators, leaf blowers and chain saws. Additionally, Bastek highlighted the storage, plumbing, and electrical categories, all which posted mid-single-digit comp growth in the quarter. Big-ticket comparable transactions — those with price tags over $1,000 — increased 4.5% in the quarter, versus the year ago period, driven by strength in power and appliances. One of the reasons that we prefer Home Depot over chief rival Lowe's is that Home Depot generates a larger portion of its revenue from professional customers, including general contractors, homebuilders and tradespeople. Home Depot has leaned into the professional lane in recent years with a series of acquisitions in the specialty distribution market — most notably, SRS Distribution for more than $18 billion in 2024 . "We are winning with the pro," Campbell said on the call. "All of our pro cohorts positively comped in the quarter, including pros shopping in the store and larger pros working on complex projects and using more of our ecosystem capabilities." Importantly, while the pro cohort outperformed do-it-yourself customers , both posted positive comps in the quarter. Thanks to investments made to help the pro better plan out complex jobs and estimate costs, Campbell noted that the team is "removing friction from every buying occasion," leading to an increasingly sticky relationship with these key customers and in turn, increased wallet share. Gross margin contracted year over year due to rising costs and a change in the sales mix as a result of acquisitions. Guidance Here's a closer look at management's updated fiscal 2026 outlook. Home Depot expects sales growth of approximately 4.5%, an increase from the previously provided 2.5% to 4.5% range. That implies revenue of about $172.09 billion, better than the Street's $171.8 billion estimate, according to LSEG. Same-store sales growth is now expected to be about 1.4%, up at the midpoint versus prior guidance for flat to up 2%. That is basically in line with the consensus estimate compiled by FactSet. The company expects a gross margin of 33%, down a tick from the 33.1% previously forecast, with an adjusted operating margin of about 12.8%, also down a bit from the 12.8% to 13% range previously provided. That compares with FactSet consensus estimates of about 33% and 12.8%, respectively. Adjusted EPS growth of about 2%, in line with the previously provided flat to up 4% range. That implies full-year earnings of $14.98 per share, a slight miss versus expectations of $15.01, according to LSEG. Given the $12.21 in earnings we've gotten in the first three quarters of the year, the guidance implies earnings of $2.77 for the current quarter, which is below the $2.81 the Street was looking for. (Jim Cramer's Charitable Trust is long HD. See here for a full list of the stocks.) As a subscriber to the CNBC Investing Club with Jim Cramer, you will receive a trade alert before Jim makes a trade. Jim waits 45 minutes after sending a trade alert before buying or selling a stock in his charitable trust's portfolio. If Jim has talked about a stock on CNBC TV, he waits 72 hours after issuing the trade alert before executing the trade. THE ABOVE INVESTING CLUB INFORMATION IS SUBJECT TO OUR TERMS AND CONDITIONS AND PRIVACY POLICY , TOGETHER WITH OUR DISCLAIMER . NO FIDUCIARY OBLIGATION OR DUTY EXISTS, OR IS CREATED, BY VIRTUE OF YOUR RECEIPT OF ANY INFORMATION PROVIDED IN CONNECTION WITH THE INVESTING CLUB. NO SPECIFIC OUTCOME OR PROFIT IS GUARANTEED.