Home › Science › Why My Family Is Suing to Stop Trump’s Arch
Science

Why My Family Is Suing to Stop Trump’s Arch

Key Points

In 1962, my father faced a novel threat to the Constitution. The governor of Mississippi had defied a federal court order and physically blocked a young Black Air Force veteran from attending the University of Mississippi. As U.S. attorney general, my father—Robert F. Kennedy—knew he had to do something.

In 1962, my father faced a novel threat to the Constitution. The governor of Mississippi had defied a federal court order and physically blocked a young Black Air Force veteran from attending the University of Mississippi. As U.S. attorney general, my father—Robert F. Kennedy—knew he had to do something. The governor was backed by a state police force that acted as his personal militia. There was, and is, no federal police force that my father or his brother, President John F. Kennedy, could deploy to deal with a lawless chief executive at the state level.

My father cobbled together a force of duly deputized U.S. marshals, many of them drawn from the ranks of the U.S. Border Patrol. He sent two courageous Justice Department attorneys—World War II veterans—to prepare the marshals before deploying them to Oxford, Mississippi. They were able, barely, to protect James Meredith on his first day at the university. Eventually, about 30,000 troops and National Guardsmen were activated to protect Meredith.

The lesson my father drew was simple: The Constitution does not enforce itself. When those sworn to uphold the law refuse to do so, someone has to find a way with the tools at hand.

Instead of a miscreant governor, the United States now has an unrepentant chief executive who treats the Department of Justice as his personal force. In 1962, the federal government would send marshals to Oxford. Today, when the lawbreaker is the commander in chief, the work falls to citizens: lawyers, nonprofits, preservation groups, and ordinary Americans who have taken this government to court again and again.

We are proud to join them. Nine members of my family—seven children and one grandchild of Robert Kennedy and one son of the late Senator Ted Kennedy—are seeking to join the litigation to stop construction of the triumphal arch that Donald Trump wants to build near Arlington National Cemetery, a sacred space for military veterans and their loved ones. The plaintiffs in the ongoing lawsuit include veterans, an architectural historian, the District of Columbia, and the Commonwealth of Virginia.

By building a gigantic memorial to himself, Trump would dishonor those who sacrificed themselves for this country. (His administration has claimed, variously, that the arch would honor the country’s 250th birthday, celebrate the troops, and serve as a military facility with snipers and drones.) The arch, modeled after the Arc de Triomphe, would be 250 feet high, more than double the height of every memorial in the capital except for the Washington Monument. Planned for a traffic circle next to the Potomac River, it would obstruct the view between the Lincoln Memorial and Arlington National Cemetery that Congress has protected for generations of Americans. An eternal flame, which has burned for more than 60 years at President Kennedy’s grave, is bright enough to be seen by visitors at the Lincoln Memorial, but that too would be blocked. In the early morning, our parents’ resting place would lie in the shadow of the overbearing arch, as would many more graves. We should not allow this vanity to veil the sacrifice of the more than 400,000 men and women buried at Arlington.

Above all, building this arch is illegal. It violates two federal statutes: the Commemorative Works Act, which details a process for creating new memorials in D.C., as well as Title 40 of the U.S. Code, Section 8106, the law that forbids construction of any building or structure on federal reservations in Washington without the approval of Congress. Congress has given no such approval. The only path open to us in attempting to rein in the president is the courts.

That is why, after reading an article that illustrates how the arch would cast shadows deep into the cemetery, we decided to seek to intervene in the litigation against Trump and the National Park Service.

My mother liked to visit our father’s grave early in the morning, before going to Mass. She would head out of the house just after sunrise and drive herself down George Washington Memorial Parkway. Most of the guards came to know her white Oldsmobile by sight and would wave her through. She took great care in placing a simple wooden cross to mark his grave, and rough paving stones that reminded them both of the seaside streets of New England. She selected these words by my father to be cut into a granite block behind the grave:

It is from numberless diverse acts of courage and belief that human history is shaped. Each time a man stands up for an ideal, or acts to improve the lot of others, or strikes out against injustice, he sends forth a tiny ripple of hope, and crossing each other from a million different centers of energy and daring those ripples build a current that can sweep down the mightiest walls of oppression and resistance.

My mother passed away two years ago and is now buried beside her husband. People visiting their shared gravesite can read that quote and then, as I have done often, look up over the granite and down a hill once owned by Robert E. Lee. They can see Arlington Memorial Bridge leading to the Lincoln Memorial, where Dr. Martin Luther King addressed the crowds of the March on Washington. Their eyes can then trace the Reflecting Pool, the National Mall, the U.S. Capitol, and, finally, beyond that, the long-neglected neighborhoods on the southeast side of Washington, framed by the old site of RFK Stadium.

Arlington Memorial Bridge symbolized the rejoining of North and South after the Civil War. Each side faces the other across an unbroken line of sight. The view across the river connects two administrations separated by a century. President Kennedy’s grave is linked to the Lincoln Memorial just as his presidency, and the Civil Rights and Voting Rights Acts that followed, carried forward Lincoln’s Emancipation Proclamation and the amendments ending slavery. This visual connection, protected by law and tradition, will be broken if Trump succeeds in building his arch.

[Sebastian Smee: The arch is atrocious]

That view did not survive by accident. The beauty of Washington, D.C., derives in no small part from the vision of its architect, Pierre Charles L’Enfant. But we owe the longevity of its greatness in large measure to our past presidents and to Congress, including dedicated members of both parties who have overseen construction of every significant memorial in the District and guarded the central axis of the city.

More than a century ago, early plans for a bridge to Arlington from Washington called for triumphal arches. The McMillan Commission, whose members included the landscape architect Frederick Law Olmsted Jr. and the sculptor Augustus Saint-Gaudens, called the arches “unusually elaborate” and rejected them. “The broader and simpler the treatment of the bridge to Arlington,” the commission wrote, “the closer will be the connection” between the two shores.

Memorial Bridge was built according to that vision, aimed straight at the Lincoln Memorial, and the view has been preserved ever since. When construction finally began in 1926, the Arlington Memorial Bridge Commission’s report stated: “In order not to interfere with the view of the Lincoln Memorial as seen from Columbia Island, the bridge has been kept as low as possible consistent with sound engineering and economy.” Notably, officials did not build a pair of columns that Congress included when it passed the law creating the bridge. The Trump administration farcically claims that those columns give it Congress’s sign-off to build the arch now.

In 1986, to permanently safeguard the capital’s lasting character and dignity, Congress passed the Commemorative Works Act. The act requires that Congress specifically approve the construction of any new monument on federal land administered by the National Park Service or the General Services Administration—including where Trump proposes to build his arch. But Congress did not foresee a president who would flout the law, alongside a Justice Department that refuses to enforce even the most basic rules against him. President Trump has previously been reported to disrespect our nation’s fallen heroes. The arch would be yet another insult to the buried war dead. And that is why we stand now: to preserve the District of Columbia for every American and to preserve this hallowed ground. The national cemetery is this nation’s most sacred monument, where those who served rest in peace and honor. The laws Congress wrote were meant to protect it. They should be enforced.

Arch (PERSON) Mississippi (LOCATION) Black Air Force (ORG) the University of Mississippi (ORG) U.S. (LOCATION) Robert F. Kennedy (PERSON) John F. Kennedy (PERSON) the U.S. Border Patrol (ORG) Justice Department (ORG) World War II (EVENT) Oxford (LOCATION) James Meredith (PERSON) National Guardsmen (ORG) Meredith (ORG) the United States (LOCATION)
Originally published by The Atlantic Read original →