Politics
NSW Labor's 'newsroom' social media account raises a political eyebrow
Key Points
analysis The NSW Labor-run social media page masquerading as a pseudo news outlet At first glance, you could be forgiven for thinking there is a new player on the New South Wales politics beat. The Instagram account called @nswnewsroom invites users to "keep up to date with news from NSW govt From a "breaking" post about the gun buyback to a video of jacarandas blooming, the newshounds have been busy.
analysis
The NSW Labor-run social media page masquerading as a pseudo news outlet
At first glance, you could be forgiven for thinking there is a new player on the New South Wales politics beat.
The Instagram account called @nswnewsroom invites users to "keep up to date with news from NSW govt [sic]".
From a "breaking" post about the gun buyback to a video of jacarandas blooming, the newshounds have been busy.
"LIBERAL LEADER SAYS SHE WOULD BE 'HAPPY TO WORK WITH ONE NATION'," screams one headline.
"JUST IN: The first metro service has left Bankstown," the page tells its readers in another.
An explainer video with glossy graphics and what sounds like an AI voiceover describes how "the Liberals used public money to build a private hospital".
The account even has a culture desk, which filed a scoop ahead of the opening of the Parramatta Powerhouse.
It is only when you leave your Instagram feed and tap through to the profile itself that the hardworking scribes at nswnewsroom are revealed.
"Authorised by D Ofner Australian Labor Party (NSW Branch) 377 Sussex Street Sydney," the bio says.
The page's first post coincided with the opening of the Bankstown Metro on October 30.
But according to a Sydney Morning Herald column on November 3, the disclosure in the bio did not appear until the paper approached the government for comment.
NSW election laws require an authorisation statement to appear on paid social media posts, but where the platform has not been paid for, the disclosure merely needs to be put in the bio.
Page's minimal mention of 'Labor'
NSW Labor's Instagram account stands in stark contrast to the pseudo news outlet.
The official party page is plastered with red, Labor logos and references to the "Minns Labor Government".
The nswnewsroom account, on the other hand, uses blue graphics and refers more generically to the "Minns government" or "NSW government".
The word "Labor" barely gets a mention. By the ABC's count on Tuesday, it appeared in just three of 28 posts.
Curiously, the outlet seemed to miss stories the government might have found embarrassing, like its recent backflips on train timetables and shelving of real estate underquoting laws.
Some of the posts feature material the government has supplied to the media to promote announcements and infrastructure projects.
The page has clips from press conferences, which the ABC understands are filmed by employees of the premier's office rather than departmental employees.
According to a 2022 circular by the Department of Premier and Cabinet, material on a government website may be reused by political parties provided the copyright and licensing arrangements permit reuse.
"Any reuse of publicly available NSW Government material should be done in a manner that does not suggest that the NSW Government endorses the political party or the use of the material by the political party," the policy states.
NSW Labor did not respond to questions sent by the ABC.
A government spokesperson said: "This is a Labor-affiliated social media page, consistent with the practices of all major political parties and a significant number of minor parties across Australia."
'Is it going to be taken as a bit of propaganda?'
Edward Hurcombe, a media researcher at RMIT University, said the page was "a bit misleading".
"It seems to be using the branding of generic news media … maybe to make sure that users don't know that this is basically PR for the New South Wales Government,"Dr Hurcombe said.
"So that is a bit concerning that it's not clearly stated outside the bio that this is messaging from the government."
University of Sydney media trust researcher Timothy Kolskie said while "you don't have to do a lot of digging" to see Labor was behind the account, some could be left with impression it was an independent news outlet.
"The bigger issue is how it's going to enter the information system that's surrounding voters," Dr Kolskie said.
"Is it going to be taken as some useful bit of information that helps them make their decision, or is it going to be taken as a bit of propaganda?"
Greens MLC Sue Higginson said the account was misleading and called for a ban on such political advertising.
"Labor Premier Chris Minns saw that Donald Trump had his own state-run TV channel, Pauline Hanson had her own fake 'One News' site, and he wanted a propaganda unit of his own," she said.
As parliament sits for the final time ahead of the March election, propaganda machines are ramping up on all sides of politics.
[Image text:] OBREAKING
ANOTHER LIBERAL
MP OUITS,ALMOST
A THIRD NOW GONE
HSC2026
TT'S OVER
YOU'VEDONEIT
MUST SEE CULTURE
POWERHOUSE
PARRAMATTA HISTORIC
OPENING
THIS SATURDAY NOV 7
ELECTION2O2
FORMER POLICE
OFFICER TO RUN
IN WINSTON HILLS
2027
ONE NATION
COALITION
MUST WATCH
NSW LIBERAL LEADER
NSW GOVERNMENT
ADDS3,000
DORNOT
NSW Labor's (ORG)
South Wales (LOCATION)
Instagram (ORG)
NSW (LOCATION)
jacarandas (PERSON)
Bankstown (LOCATION)
AI (ORG)
Liberals (ORG)
the Parramatta Powerhouse (ORG)
Ofner Australian Labor Party (ORG)
NSW Branch (ORG)
Sussex Street Sydney (ORG)
the Bankstown Metro (LOCATION)
Sydney Morning Herald (ORG)
Labor (ORG)