Tyra Banks had a tip for how contestants on America’s Next Top Model should present themselves: “Ho, but make it fashion.” Secretary of State Marco Rubio’s recent speeches update the message with a twist: “Traditional American foreign policy, but make it obnoxious.” Twice in six weeks, Rubio has delivered addresses filled with classic conservative beliefs, but seasoned with the kind of racism, sexism, and enthusiasm for lawless power that has become common in the age of Trump.
At a Federalist Society conference Friday evening, Rubio offered an explanation for the Trump administration’s decision last month to impose sanctions on what he called the “fake” International Criminal Court—a move apparently made in retaliation against the ICC’s investigation of alleged U.S. war crimes in Afghanistan. In making his case, Rubio had two options. The first would have been to point out that every American administration of the past three decades has rejected ICC jurisdiction over U.S. personnel. As president, Bill Clinton, Barack Obama, and Joe Biden all expressed openness to the ICC—but only if the court accepted some kind of U.S. veto. The case for this option is that it would have created the broadest possible coalition behind the Trump administration’s position. This was the approach George W. Bush’s administration took in the early 2000s, citing Clinton’s qualms about the ICC to support Bush’s stronger stance against the court.
The second option was for Rubio to deliver a message of skepticism about the ICC, but going pedal-to-the-metal culture war. This, unfortunately, was the option Rubio went for. In explaining the administration’s policy toward the ICC, Rubio cited a line attributed to the Roman general Pompey: “Stop quoting laws to men with swords.” Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth liked the bit so much, he reposted it on X, capping “MEN WITH SWORDS.”
[Read: The dangerous idea Rubio and Hegseth are endorsing]
Watch the video of these remarks, and you’ll hear nervous laughter after Rubio’s Pompey reference. When he noticed that his big applause line had misfired, Rubio flashed an apologetic smile and improvised: “Not politically correct to say that, but that’s what he said!” The attempted regroup extracted more chuckles but scant applause.
Rubio was speaking to an ultra-friendly room. The majority of the conservative lawyers convened before him surely agreed with his preceding point about the ICC: “They think they have the right to rule over everyone, but they are accountable to no one, armed with the power to investigate, to prosecute, to persecute, and to jail our citizens according to laws we neither consent nor control.” But American lawyers—even conservative ones—will not agree that the capacity to do violence exempts armed men from the law.
We know Pompey’s views on men with swords because they appear in Plutarch’s collection of short biographies of eminent Greeks and Romans. Plutarch’s Pompey is no hero, but a man of great gifts laid low by bad judgment. After the Bible, Plutarch’s Lives ranked high among the books read by America’s Founding Fathers. James Madison, the country’s fourth president and Rubio’s predecessor as secretary of state by more than 215 years, had little good to say about warlords such as Pompey: “The liberties of Rome proved the final victim to her military triumphs.”
Rubio has a reputation as one of the Trump’s administration’s less irresponsible figures. But his approach to rhetoric lately seems borrowed from a story told about Franklin D. Roosevelt by his aide, Raymond Moley. During the presidential campaign of 1932, Moley showed Roosevelt two competing drafts of a big economic speech. One called for junking tariffs. The other endorsed them. Which approach, Moley asked, would the candidate prefer? “Weave the two together,” Roosevelt replied. Rubio likewise sometimes presents himself as the last voice of Republican internationalism, a defender of America’s long history of democratic alliances and partnerships. Other times, he remembers that this music no longer moves his party under Trump—and instead deploys language that is bombastic, vituperative, and needlessly disparaging.
In Rubio’s speech on democracy in Athens last month, for example, he swerved from praising the pursuit of knowledge to delivering an encomium to violent conquest: “The hunger for new knowledge, that’s what gave birth to Magellan’s first expedition around the world, to Columbus’s discovery of the Americas, and ultimately to Apollo 11’s journey to the moon. And the qualities that led Alexander to conquer the entire known world reappeared in Caesar, then Charlemagne, and Cortes.”
Rubio’s Federalist Society speech was mostly about international law, but it included a completely unnecessary passage that implied that Native Americans are not part of the American “we.” He said, “When our predecessors first arrived in North America, when they first came, there were no factories, there were no railroads, there were no skyscrapers. These things exist because we built them, because we acted. These things exist because we acted without fear or moral doubt and overcame all that which threatened or stood in our way.”
[Read: Trump sets the olive branch on fire]
These speeches deploy gendered language (“the men who founded my country”; “the men who built backwater colonies into the greatest superpower on Earth”; “the men who made the Parthenon”; “the sons of Athens and Rome”) with an emphasis and frequency that must have raised eyebrows even in a Trump-administration communications department. When I wrote speeches for a Republican administration more than a quarter century ago, language that obliviously elided about half of the human race would have earned me a zinger from one of the administration’s many high-ranking women.
For the Cabinet secretary charged with the care of alliances and institutions, such fretting over the mollycoddling do-gooders who are crushing the spirits of the Nietzschean supermen among us is unusual. But in his speech in Greece, Rubio lamented that Western institutions care more for “the comfort of the worst than the potential of the best,” adding: “We hold the most exceptional things among us hostage to the average, the ordinary, the mediocre.”
To the Federalist Society, Rubio complained of how “international lawyers and jurists and NGOs and UN bureaucrats” conspire to persuade the United States “to relinquish responsibility for our own destiny and to relieve ourselves of the burdens of greatness and seek refuge in these glittering generalities of international law.” He expressed annoyance that the president “cannot restrict trade or immigration or even examine the way in which we spend our citizens’ tax dollars abroad without facing the fury” of these meddlesome international bodies: “Even as we defeated the institution of Soviet communism, we did not triumph over the spirit of Marx.”
But it was not Karl Marx who struck down Trump’s attempts to exert unilateral presidential authority over trade and immigration. It was America’s own courts—in many cases led by Federalist Society–style judges—that ruled against Trump’s claims that the president can impose tariffs at will and overturn birthright citizenship by executive order.
What’s achieved by these bizarre excursions down such malign byways? The early bidding for the 2028 Republican presidential nomination is shaping up as a contest among Vice President Vance, Florida Governor Ron DeSantis, and a widening field that includes Rubio and Senator Ted Cruz of Texas. Like Vance, Rubio has seemed to intuit that the way to prove one’s mettle in a party remade by Trump is to present oneself as gratuitously nasty. But this is an odd gamble at a time when the president’s own gratuitous nastiness has inspired the country’s turn away from him and his party.