Sport
Matchup rankings for Week 11: Why you should start one 49er, but sit another
Key Points
Beware the seafaring teams. The Minnesota Vikings, Seattle Seahawks and Tampa Bay Buccaneers have been head and shoulders the toughest overall matchups for fantasy football opponents all season, and they should be almost universally avoided at this stage. (Sorry, Miami Dolphins, but ... better luck next year?)
Beware the seafaring teams.
The Minnesota Vikings, Seattle Seahawks and Tampa Bay Buccaneers have been head and shoulders the toughest overall matchups for fantasy football opponents all season, and they should be almost universally avoided at this stage. (Sorry, Miami Dolphins, but ... better luck next year?)
In addition to their positional ratings over the past five weeks alone that we'll get to shortly, the Vikings, Seahawks and Buccaneers have been, with one exception, top-seven schedule adjusted defenses against quarterbacks, running backs, wide receivers, WR1s and tight ends. The Buccaneers grant that one exception, ranking 21st for the season against tight ends, so... fire up Sam LaPorta? (Or don't, for reasons we'll also get to a little later on.)
As we've seen this past week with the once high-flying Green Bay Packers, no one is safe from the dreaded Vikings matchup. None of Jordan Love, Matthew Golden or Christian Watson exceeded 12 fantasy points in Week 10, and over their past five games, only four players reached even the 17-point plateau against the Vikings: Jonathan Taylor (Week 7), Jahmyr Gibbs and Jameson Williams (Week 8) and James Cook III (Week 9).
That's a critical takeaway considering how prominent the Vikings' Week 11 matchup. They'll visit a San Francisco 49ers team that ranks first in total yards per game (399.8) and third in points per game on offense (29.7), and whose starting running back (Christian McCaffrey) just scored the season's highest single-game fantasy point total (46.3). It's quite a matchup and in primetime, no less.
This isn't a mandate to bench McCaffrey. But it's that suboptimal matchup that influences lineup strategy. Going more risk/reward from your other lineup spots, fading in Daily Fantasy and certainly steering clear of McCaffrey's teammates where possible ... it's all on the table.
It's a similar case with the Detroit Lions and the aforementioned Gibbs, as they go up against the massively underrated Buccaneers defense. Again, don't sit him and aim to surround him with higher-ceiling, plus-matchup players who can help make up any of the No. 1 fantasy football player's matchup deficiencies.
Here are this week's Matchup Rankings, to help give you a head start on finding those matchup-driven values. If you're curious about the methodology behind these rankings, select here for a handy primer.
Quarterbacks
Matchups highlight: Tyler Shough, New Orleans Saints (at Chicago Bears). Though his performance has cooled from his scorching-hot September that had him on the doorstop of weekly fantasy QB1 status, Shough has had his moments thus far as an NFL starter. Since Week 9 of last season, his five game-winning drives are tied for fifth-most in the league and he has a better-than-league-average 97.1 passer rating while trailing in the second half or overtime. Shough's moxie under pressure could prove especially advantageous in a Bears matchup -- one that has been extremely favorable for quarterbacks in all game situations -- being that his Saints are 6.5 point underdogs in a game with a 48.5 over/under.
Others to like:
Dak Prescott, Dallas Cowboys (versus Tennessee Titans)
Kirk Cousins, Vikings (at 49ers, "Sunday Night Football")
Matchup to avoid: Brock Purdy, 49ers (versus Vikings, SNF). Where the aforementioned McCaffrey gets a pass on the matchup, Purdy isn't so fortunate. Fantasy's No. 3 quarterback in scoring has fallen into his matchups, as his two 30-plus-point performances came in his two most favorable (ARI, @DAL), while he scored 16.16, his second-worst total all year, in his least favorable (@SEA). And this is a terrible one, against which top-12 quarterbacks (going by points per game) Josh Allen, Jordan Love, Jared Goff and Caleb Williams averaged 10.1 fantasy points with a 12.86 max (Allen's, in Week 9). Additional note: Goff gets an unfavorable Buccaneers matchup this week, but as the QB11 in scoring, he's a lower-tier sit.
Running backs
Matchups highlight: Jonah Coleman, Denver Broncos (versus Las Vegas Raiders). His ascent to the top of the Broncos' depth chart has been quick and decisive. In Weeks 8-9, he played 75% of the offensive snaps and had a 56% rushing share, with which he averaged 19.6 fantasy points. Now fresh off the bye week, Coleman draws a matchup with the Raiders in a game where his Broncos are heavily favored, making him a clear-cut fantasy RB1. The Raiders have seen an opposing running back score in excess of 17 fantasy points in five of their past six games, and in the one in which they didn't, the Seahawks' Zach Charbonnet and Jadarian Price combined for 20.8 points despite failing to see a single goal-line carry or target.
Others to like:
Tony Pollard, Titans (at Cowboys)
Omarion Hampton, Los Angeles Chargers (versus New York Jets)
David Montgomery, Houston Texans (versus Indianapolis Colts, "Thursday Night Football")
Matchup to avoid: Ollie Gordon II, Dolphins (at Buffalo Bills). Neither Gibbs nor McCaffrey is a sit-him in "Bye-mageddon" Week 11, but Gordon, despite being a difficult player to bench with a depleted positional pool, might as well be. The opposing Bills are scorching hot defensively, limiting opponents to a league-low 9.3 points and second-lowest 232.7 total yards per game in three weeks since their bye, and they held opposing No. 1 running backs to 10.6 fantasy points and 11.3 touches during that time. The Bills began the week 11.5 point favorites, meaning this might be the fourth straight week their opponent faces negative game script.
Wide receivers
Matchups highlight: Carnell Tate, Titans (at Cowboys). It speaks volumes about the poor quality of the defenses that a game featuring two teams with a combined 5-14 record has the week's highest over/under (54.5 points). For the season, the Cowboys have been the fifth most-favorable matchup for an opposing wide receiver (+4.5 Adj. FPA), and sixth most for WR1s (+2.5) and in the past four weeks alone, Makai Lemon, Michael Wilson and Deebo Samuel Sr. has each scored at least 19 fantasy points against them. Tate, who missed the Titans' past two games with a shoulder issue, is expected back in time to assume WR1 duties in this plus matchup. But if he's unable to go, Elic Ayomanor and Chimere Dike would become WR3/flex options.
Others to like:
Garrett Wilson, Jets (at Chargers)
George Pickens, Cowboys (versus Titans)
Stefon Diggs, Washington Commanders (versus Cincinnati Bengals, Monday Night Football)
Matchup to avoid: Emeka Egbuka, Buccaneers (at Lions). The Lions, specifically against wide receivers, have one of the most interesting early-season/recent splits I've seen in recent memory. From Weeks 1-5, their Adj. FPA was +8.3, second-most in the league. In five weeks (and four games) since, that number is minus-9.0 and is third fewest. That coincides with the healthy return of Brian Branch, granting the Lions more opportunities to key on the opposing No. 1 receiver. WR1s have averaged only 8.5 fantasy points and 6.5 targets against the Lions the past four weeks, and Egbuka's team-leading 28% target share when he's on the field makes him their probable focal point defensively.
Tight ends
Matchups highlight: Mike Gesicki, Bengals (at Commanders). The Commanders are second only to the Lions in terms of their struggles against opposing tight ends, representing their seasonal ranking in fantasy points per game allowed (20.2), Adj. FPA (+6.7) and fantasy points per target (2.24). In the red zone, the Commanders have performed especially poorly against tight ends, affording them the second-most yards per attempt (8.5), second-most touchdowns (9) and second-highest passer rating (129.9). Gesicki is a fantasy shot in the dark, as the player averaging by far the fewest targets per touchdown (4.7), but he's an especially attractive one in a heavy bye week and with a matchup like this.
Matchup to avoid: Sam LaPorta, Lions (versus Buccaneers). As mentioned above, the Buccaneers have been a below-average defense against tight ends from a seasonal standpoint, but over the past five weeks they've improved in that regard significantly. Having their cornerbacks absorb more of those coverage assignments has helped, especially in their two games immediately preceding the bye, in which Kyle Pitts Sr. and Colston Loveland combined for 12.0 fantasy points on 11 targets. LaPorta might find it difficult to find open space frequently in this matchup.
Vikings (LOCATION)
Seattle Seahawks (ORG)
Tampa Bay Buccaneers (LOCATION)
Miami Dolphins (PERSON)
Seahawks (LOCATION)
Sam LaPorta (PERSON)
Green Bay Packers (ORG)
Jordan Love (PERSON)
Matthew Golden (PERSON)
Christian Watson (PERSON)
Jonathan Taylor (PERSON)
Jahmyr Gibbs (PERSON)
Jameson Williams (PERSON)
James Cook III (PERSON)
San Francisco (LOCATION)