Home › World News › Europe argued over who would talk to Russia. Agreeing...
World News

Europe argued over who would talk to Russia. Agreeing what to say is even tougher.

Europe argued over who would talk to Russia. Agreeing what to say is even tougher.
Key Points

After the EU and its allies wrestled over who should represent them in talks over Ukraine, they now face an even harder decision: play hardball with Russia or try a subtler approach? The challenge of agreeing on red lines, or principles, for the European team in any negotiations is already proving divisive, with the EU’s chief diplomat Kaja Kallas saying the Europeans should start by demanding as much as possible, and some governments, such as Austria, advocating a looser approach,...

BRUSSELS ― After the EU and its allies wrestled over who should represent them in talks over Ukraine, they now face an even harder decision: play hardball with Russia or try a subtler approach?

The challenge of agreeing on red lines, or principles, for the European team in any negotiations is already proving divisive, with the EU’s chief diplomat Kaja Kallas saying the Europeans should start by demanding as much as possible, and some governments, such as Austria, advocating a looser approach, including confidence-building measures.

“There’s a range of things that Europe should make clear that it’s not ready to discuss,” Norway’s Foreign Minister Espen Barth Eide said.

Europe was largely left out of talks between Russia, Ukraine and the U.S. in Abu Dhabi last week, but the Kremlin and the White House signaled that wouldn’t be the case at future meetings. After days of disagreement, EU leaders settled on a team made up of officials from four major countries ― France, Germany, Italy and Poland ― plus the U.K. and top representatives from NATO and the European Commission and Council.

Now, “the focus must shift from the ‘who’ to the ‘what’,” Austrian Foreign Minister Beate Meinl-Reisinger said.

In a 15-point paper shared ahead of a foreign ministers’ meeting on Monday, Austria spelled out what some of those confidence-building measures could be: proposing limited or partial ceasefires to pave the way for a wider truce, for instance, or offering to set up an international forum to monitor any peace agreement. 

Austria’s Foreign Minister Beate Meinl-Reisinger speaks during the 81st United Nations General Assembly at UN headquarters in New York on September 24, 2026. | Leonardo Munoz/AFP via Getty Images

The proposal amounts to “an offer to all 27 [EU countries] to work towards a common position,” Meinl-Reisinger said.

Norway, which isn’t part of Europe’s negotiating team but had direct contacts with Russia, is also floating ideas to lower tensions. Ukraine’s backers should look back to the Cold War for examples of how Russia and the West managed extreme tensions, specifically the 1975 “Helsinki Accords” which laid out principles for state-to-state relations, Foreign Minister Barth Eide said.

“NATO deployments in NATO countries, for instance, is not a question to discuss with Russia” but Cold War deals on arms limitation “must be relevant in the post-war scenario.”

In the same vein, officials close to the talks are calling for a “flexible” mandate that would allow participants to actually negotiate, rather than have their hands tied. The job of drafting the mandate must go to EU ambassadors in their Coreper meetings, not foreign ministers, argued two EU officials.

Further complicating the matter, such a mandate would bind the European representatives at the table ― the Commission’s Bjoern Seibert, the European Council’s Anna-Maria Boura and the advisers from France, Poland, Italy and Germany ― but not those from the U.K. or NATO.

Game theory

For Kallas, however, it should be the foreign ministers she gathers in Brussels each month who draft the mandate — and as far as she’s concerned, the approach should demand up-front concessions from Russia rather than the other way around.

Mette Frederiksen, Andy Burnham and Kaja Kallas during a roundtable at the European Political Community summit at the Convention Centre on November 12, 2026, in Dublin. | WPA pool photo by Stefan Rousseau/Getty Images

“The foreign ministers are ready to take this work forward,” she told reporters on Monday, pointing out that she had already suggested a list of demands.

“I was a lawyer,” she said. “How do you enter negotiations? First, you present or prepare the absolute maximum you want to see. Then, not openly, you also prepare where you are ready to … step back to and what are your red lines, which are absolute no-gos.” 

Ministers from several Baltic, Nordic and eastern flank countries echoed Kallas’s approach.

“We have to really keep sequencing, and it means that we have to agree on the ceasefire and when the guns go silent, then we negotiate on the long-lasting peace on Ukraine,” Lithuanian Foreign Minister Kęstutis Budrys said. 

Estonia’s chief envoy, Margus Tsahkna, echoed the point: “First, Putin can start the ceasefire. Then negotiations between Russia and Ukraine about peace, and if the peace is there, we need to discuss what kind of security guarantees will be given to Ukraine. We also need Ukrainian security guarantees to our region.”

The only problem is that Europe has already effectively conceded that talks will continue even without a ceasefire. EU negotiators see talks resuming in the coming weeks in Abu Dhabi and are banking on being in the room with Russia’s representatives, according to two EU officials, despite the fact that Moscow is carrying out daily attacks across Ukraine.

“It’s about being pragmatic,” said a senior EU official, granted anonymity to speak frankly. “The people in the room must be able to make decisions.”

Europe (LOCATION) Russia (LOCATION) BRUSSELS (LOCATION) EU (ORG) Ukraine (LOCATION) European (ORG) Kaja Kallas (PERSON) Europeans (ORG) Austria (LOCATION) Espen Barth Eide (PERSON) U.S. (LOCATION) Abu Dhabi (LOCATION) Kremlin (ORG) the White House (ORG) France (LOCATION)
Originally published by Politico EU Read original →