Sport
Wetzel: Welcome to Round 2 of LSU vs. the SEC
Key Points
By playing R.J. Luis in a basketball game Wednesday, LSU has chosen violence -- not in the physical sense, but in a way that causes people to call their lawyers and start parsing through SEC bylaws. Balled-up fists are kind of LSU's thing, though, at least when its unofficial wartime consigliere, Jeff Landry, gets involved. Officially, he's the state's governor, not the LSU president or athletic director, but this being Louisiana, what difference does it really make?
By playing R.J. Luis in a basketball game Wednesday, LSU has chosen violence -- not in the physical sense, but in a way that causes people to call their lawyers and start parsing through SEC bylaws.
Balled-up fists are kind of LSU's thing, though, at least when its unofficial wartime consigliere, Jeff Landry, gets involved. Officially, he's the state's governor, not the LSU president or athletic director, but this being Louisiana, what difference does it really make?
Of course, ask LSU, and it would say the same negative things about the SEC, which has spent the past few months confronting the Tigers by writing new rules while Callin' Baton Rouge every name in the book, be it in federal court filings or administrator groups text threads.
The sport is different this time -- basketball, not football. So too is the wry, renegade, indifferent-to-the-chaos-and-criticism-around-him coach -- Will Wade, not Lane Kiffin.
Pretty much everything else is the same -- namely LSU finding a local judge to declare, at least for now, that a guy should be allowed to return from the professional ranks to the college game.
In August, it was a couple of football players who were cut from NFL training camps and tried to go back to school.
This time it is Luis, who after being named 2024-25 Big East Player of the Year at St. John's, declared for the NBA draft. He went unselected that night, but signed a two-way deal with the Utah Jazz and was later part of a trade to the Boston Celtics.
Luis never actually played in any NBA or even G League games, but intent, as the saying goes, is nine-tenths of the law. Inconsistent 3-point shooting covers the rest.
Regardless, we get a redo from the summer.
LSU says Luis should be able to come back, in part because he never, kind of, sort of, left. Everyone else is outraged, whether it's because of honestly held principles or fear of taking on a suddenly strong-ass roster Wade has assembled.
(An aside for the casual observer: Yes, Will Wade once coached LSU, and you might remember him getting fired after he was caught on an FBI wire discussing payments to players, which was, at the time, not allowed. That did happen. However, since the rules changed -- "NIL stands for Now It's Legal," Wade joked -- the school rehired him last offseason because while his espionage avoidance skills aren't great, no one ever said the man wasn't one heck of a basketball coach.)
Who is right and who is wrong here rests mostly in your fandom, or whoever answers to "Your Honor" down at the courthouse.
In the past, what Luis did was permitted -- other NCAA and SEC teams have added players who have been drafted into the NBA and even played in the G League or overseas.
However, last August, in response to Kiffin combing the NFL waiver wire for late pickups to exploit a temporary loophole in NCAA rules, the SEC passed a rule banning such a thing. Luis' argument is that since he started the process of returning to college before the SEC passed its new "no pro players" rule, it shouldn't apply to him.
An East Baton Rouge Parish judge, conveniently located 2.7 miles from the Pete Maravich Center, agreed and granted Luis a preliminary injunction. That set off a war of words, including from LSU, which has taken the stance of -- well, I guess we'll just have to obey the courts and add a potential All-American.
"LSU is committed to compliance with the NCAA and SEC rules," the school said in a statement, which, like pretty much every SEC school, isn't completely backed up by its historical track record, "... but it is equally committed to obey the orders of Louisiana's courts."
The SEC countered by stating LSU's actions are "inconsistent with the expectations and responsibilities of membership in the Southeastern Conference. This is a deeply concerning and disappointing development."
"Deeply concerning and disappointing" is doing a lot of work here. Apoplectic is a better description. The term "outlaw program" is being thrown around a lot by SEC coaches and administrators.
Since LSU backed down when it came to football, few thought LSU would actually dare play Luis and take this to DEFCON 1.
Yet there he was Wednesday scoring 11 points and grabbing nine rebounds in LSU's 79-67 victory over UL-Monroe. Additionally, Luis' attorney tossed gas on the fire via a motion demanding the SEC and its commissioner, Greg Sankey, be held in contempt of court for its statement.
There is now significant talk within the league of boycotting games against the Tigers, multiple SEC ADs told ESPN. Lawyers have been summoned to find out, among other things, if such an action would count as a no-contest or a loss in the eyes of the NCAA tournament selection committee.
Georgia Attorney General Chris Carr didn't hold back, writing, as he did back in August, a letter to the SEC demanding significant penalties against LSU "up to and including expulsion" from a league the Tigers helped found in 1932.
Wednesday was particularly entertaining after a federal judge in Alabama harshly questioned an LSU attorney over a legal filing in which the school claimed the SEC "hallucinated" citations in a separate court filing because it might have used AI in some capacity.
The lawyer says the briefing was written by Louisiana's state solicitor general, not him.
Either way, the judge was unimpressed and demanded LSU issue "heartfelt" and "robust" public statements essentially apologizing for the hallucination accusation. That went over like a "Roll Tide" chant back in Baton Rouge, where the state's attorney general, Liz Murrill, declared it "improper for an Alabama federal judge to compel speech from the State of Louisiana."
(By the way, invoking a federal judge with a First Amendment reference is the legal equivalent to squaring off in a bar fight and making fun of the other guy's mother).
Grandstanding aside, the battle lines have been drawn.
Luis has his argument and his injunction and the highest levels of state government backing him. The SEC, meanwhile, doesn't lack for league members who are sick of the Tigers' antics -- just because you can get a local judge to declare something, they argue, doesn't mean you should.
Everyone thinks they are correct and the other side is just a bunch of hypocrites trying to gain an edge.
The Madness has arrived early this season.