Home › Education › Consider law to curb marriage between relatives: SC to govt
Education

Consider law to curb marriage between relatives: SC to govt

Consider law to curb marriage between relatives: SC to govt
Key Points

govt must explore the legislative route to prevent marriage between close relatives NEW DELHI: The ordeal of a 20-year-old Bengaluru-based woman who defied serious physical conditions to gain admission to an elite law school became the trigger for a fresh Supreme Court push for a uniform civil code (UCC).Moved by her plight, the court said Friday the Union govt must explore the legislative route to prevent marriage between close relatives, prevalent among Muslims and some Hindu communities...

govt must explore the legislative route to prevent marriage between close relatives NEW DELHI: The ordeal of a 20-year-old Bengaluru-based woman who defied serious physical conditions to gain admission to an elite law school became the trigger for a fresh Supreme Court push for a uniform civil code (UCC).Moved by her plight, the court said Friday the Union govt must explore the legislative route to prevent marriage between close relatives, prevalent among Muslims and some Hindu communities in the south, to protect their offspring against genetic disorders.Born to parents who are first cousins, the LLB student at National Law School of India University who suffers from genetic disorders photophobia and cone dystrophy, pleaded in her PIL that exceptions carved out to allow marriage between close relatives must be ended to give offspring the right to a healthy life."Should the law continue to retain statutory and customary exceptions that permit marriages between close blood relatives, notwithstanding established medical evidence that such unions significantly increase risk of autosomal recessive disorders, congenital anomalies, disabilities, infant morbidity and other lifelong health issues in children?" she asked.Photophobia is an abnormal intolerance of light, while cone dystrophy causes breakdown of cone photoreceptor cells in the retina. Children in marriages between close relatives are at greater risk of inheriting two copies of the altered recessive gene from the parents, leading to genetic disorders.The PIL challenged the custom-based exceptions preserved in Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, and Special Marriage Act, 1954.A bench of Chief Justice Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana was convinced the problem would be best addressed through the legislative route rather than a symptomatic judicial antidote.Quoting National Family Health Survey data, the petitioner said consanguineous marriages (marriages between people related by blood) were deeply entrenched in cultural, religious and social practices. According to NFHS, "13% of ever-married women were related to their husband before their marriage, and 11% of marriages were consanguineous marriages. The most common type of consanguineous marriages were marriages to first cousins (8% of all marriages)."The survey said, "Women in urban areas are about equally as likely to be in consanguineous marriages as women in rural areas. Muslim and Buddhist/Neo-Buddhist women are the most likely to be in consanguineous marriages." It had put the rate of such marriages among Muslims at 15.8%, among Buddhists/Neo-Buddhists at 14.5%, among Christians at 11.9%, and among Hindus at 10.1%.The survey further said, "Women in all southern states except Kerala are much more likely to be in consanguineous marriages than women in other states. More than one-fourth of women in Tamil Nadu, Andhra Pradesh and Karnataka, and almost one-fifth of women in Telangana and Puducherry reported being in consanguineous marriages."The bench sought Centre's response on two aspects - the desirability of legislation to prevent consanguineous marriages, and an awareness campaign on possible adverse genetic disorders afflicting children from marriage between blood relatives, including making it a part of school and college curricula. The petitioner said, "Children should not be subjected to preventable and irreversible genetic risks, especially when the law continues to defer to custom where constitutional protection, public health and child welfare are at stake.""Consanguineous marriages pose a... demonstrable threat to public health, particularly to the right to life and health of children born out of such unions, who are disproportionately susceptible to congenital and genetic disorders bey-ond their control," she said.
SC (LOCATION) NEW DELHI (LOCATION) Bengaluru (LOCATION) Supreme Court (ORG) Muslims (ORG) Hindu (ORG) LLB (ORG) National Law School of India University (ORG) PIL (ORG) Surya Kant (PERSON) Joymalya Bagchi (PERSON) National Family Health Survey (ORG) NFHS (ORG) Muslim (ORG) Buddhist (ORG)
Originally published by Times of India Read original →