Home › Entertainment › Hollywood Needs a New Pixar
Entertainment

Hollywood Needs a New Pixar

Key Points

Hollywood earned its cultural monopoly by absorbing radical technologies that it first resisted: sound, color, computer graphics. People in the industry initially feared that Pixar’s computer animation would replace human actors with “digital doubles.” Similarly, most of the conversation about AI today revolves around cost savings and artist displacement.

Hollywood earned its cultural monopoly by absorbing radical technologies that it first resisted: sound, color, computer graphics. People in the industry initially feared that Pixar’s computer animation would replace human actors with “digital doubles.” Similarly, most of the conversation about AI today revolves around cost savings and artist displacement. These issues are important, but they miss an even bigger shift that AI is accelerating. Ask a teenager where their favorite characters come from, and the answer is as likely to be a creator platform—YouTube, Roblox, TikTok—as a Hollywood studio. Unless moviemakers evolve, they risk losing their place at the center of culture. Those who combine new technology with storytelling, and who bring audiences into the creative process, will define the next century of entertainment.

Silicon Valley and Hollywood went through a version of this before, during the early partnership between Pixar and Disney that was crucial to Pixar’s success. Disney storytellers gave Pixar pointed feedback on early Pixar characters, leading John Lasseter, Pete Docter, and the rest of the brain trust to take screenwriting classes. Pixar didn’t believe that technical people were any less creative than artists. Every discipline mattered. The result: Toy Story.

Disney didn’t produce Toy Story by hiring more CGI artists into its 2-D pipeline. Instead, it partnered with Pixar, whose mission was to make movies with the new technology, and eventually acquired it. Pixar had tech that worked, artists who were intimate with it, and a culture of mutual admiration among its artistic and technological creators. Disney had marketing, distribution, major capital, logistical know-how, and a glorious legacy. Neither could build what the other had.

Something similar needs to happen now. Hollywood has an opportunity to partner with studios built for AI, but the rise of creator culture will make the transition harder. During the shift to computer animation and graphics in the 1980s and ’90s, the distribution formats stayed the same—theaters, home video, and broadcast. Today, format, distribution, and production technology are changing all at once.

[Read: The corner of Hollywood that’s most susceptible to AI]

YouTube made more than $60 billion last year, about $15 billion more than Netflix brought in. To keep up, Hollywood studios are adapting properties from creator platforms. They found success with Backrooms (which cost about $10 million to make but collected more than $400 million at the box office) and Obsession (less than $1 million to make; more than $520 million at the box office), and are now rushing to find more YouTube properties and talent. Though this is smart, these audiences were formed and cultivated on other platforms. The Minecraft movie made almost $1 billion, a fraction of the game franchise’s $10 to $12 billion. The movie was effectively a marketing event for the game.

AI didn’t cause the shift to creator platforms, but it will accelerate it. MrBeast, who has more than 500 million YouTube subscribers, built an empire without AI, but the technology allows would-be creators to realize their visions, and it enables existing creators to work more efficiently.  

But what about the ethics of using AI models that were trained on artists’ work without their permission or payment? Artists should be compensated for the work that was used to train models. These issues need to be settled in court and through regulation and licensing. The technology won’t go away, so we need artists to help set its terms.

But rejecting AI altogether is not the answer. Across Asia, creators face many of the same concerns, but the technological and cultural shift is further along. In China, microdramas—scripted series typically filmed in portrait mode and designed for smartphone viewing, with episodes lasting one to three minutes—have compressed the distance between creation, distribution, and monetization; generative AI fits naturally into an industrial ecosystem built around rapid iteration, low production costs, and huge volumes of content. In Korea, webtoons and web novels move across streaming, games, music, and other formats. In India, a multilingual audience creates especially strong incentives for AI-assisted dubbing. It is a misperception that creators in the Global South care less about copyright, labor costs, or artistic integrity—if anything, Asia’s creator industries are quickly converging with the West on these questions. The difference is that much of the experimentation is happening within entertainment industries that have been more entrepreneurial and are more willing to embrace new technology.

The first “Toy Story moment” for both AI and the new formats it enables—a work whose artistic and cultural appeal makes the technology itself almost beside the point—may not be far away. The companies and countries that achieve it first could change perceptions of AI in creative work and accrue outsize cultural reach. In that sense, the U.S.-China technology competition is also becoming a competition over who builds the tools, platforms, and creative communities that shape global culture.

Hollywood has defined mainstream culture for a century, and storytelling remains its greatest asset. However, treating YouTube, Roblox, and TikTok as farm systems to feed traditional distribution misses that audiences are on the farm.

Netflix recently laid off 1,000 employees; Disney laid off roughly 1,500 this year and has said more layoffs are coming. Skydance’s co-CEOs have told staff to expect layoffs too. Studios have focused on cutting costs, but Hollywood needs to build for new formats, not just make old ones cheaper.

Hollywood needs to fundamentally shift the way it operates, moving from producing finished products meant for passive consumption to developing stories and characters using input from their audiences. Instead of performing autopsies in hindsight, every major studio could put out drafts and iterate with audiences, the way creators do. Kane Parsons started Backrooms with one YouTube short and expanded it into a series when audiences responded positively. Vivienne Medrano released a fan-financed YouTube pilot of Hazbin Hotel; A24 ordered a full series after it drew a huge following.

Refining work using audience input doesn’t mean asking fans to vote on every creative choice. Strong directors have always filtered feedback, taking notes that tighten their narrative and discarding what dilutes their core vision. Borrowing a page from tech, studios could also be much more rigorous with data sourcing, A/B testing, and analysis to understand their audience’s behavior.

This audience-centered approach can be applied to all parts of moviemaking. Films that perform well after an inexpensive tease, such as an animatic (storyboards that are cut together), can secure financing quickly, because financiers aren’t being asked to gamble many millions of dollars on an untested idea. Marketing happens in parallel with production. Your audience becomes not just fans but ambassadors, because they feel they are part of the process. The production becomes part of the story. Markiplier, a YouTuber whose real name is Mark Fischbach, created and financed a film, Iron Lung, which he planned to release in a small number of independent theaters. His fans emailed exhibitors until national chains picked it up.

Vision is not replaced by data; instead, data can help studios find the audiences for visionary work, position it well, and understand which ambitious projects have real demand before committing hundreds of millions of dollars to them. If Orson Welles could have shared his early ideas with audiences in the 1940s, while making Citizen Kane, data wouldn’t have diluted the ambition of his deep-focus shots, broken timeline, and montages. Analyzing the public feedback could have helped him find his audience faster.

Hollywood has a finite window to make these changes. Creators who already operate this way, such as MrBeast, are building their own production studios and will have less incentive to partner. Others will follow.

[Rose Horowitch: The film students who can no longer sit through films]

Studios are experimenting by launching short phone series on YouTube and TikTok, signing deals with top creators, and hiring creator-platform experts into executive positions. This is smart, but these initiatives still prioritize bringing existing franchises to new screens over developing stories alongside audiences. Dropping a digital executive into a traditional, risk-averse studio pipeline doesn’t change the entire studio’s culture. The business model, people, and creative culture that make a great film studio differ from those that are best for building a YouTube series or Roblox game.

Hollywood doesn’t need to become a tech company, and Silicon Valley shouldn’t arrogantly assume that tech is superior to a story’s ability to move culture. Legacy studios still have what many creators need: capital, global marketing, distribution know-how, and deep story expertise. Just as Disney secured its future by partnering with and acquiring Pixar, today’s legacy studios need to collaborate with a new class of studios, ones that know how to build on creator platforms, are rooted in Hollywood storytelling, and treat technologists and artists equally.

The Disney-Pixar relationship worked because Bob Iger gave Pixar co-founder Ed Catmull real power over Disney Animation. Other Hollywood acquisitions of gaming studios or creator talent have struggled when the acquired company lacked similar authority. A real partnership would allow legacy media to originate ideas on new platforms instead of being licensing arms for new players.

AI will have its Toy Story moment. The studios that achieve it will know how to reach audiences on newer platforms, in formats that bring the audience along for the ride.

Hollywood Needs (ORG) Pixar (ORG) AI (ORG) YouTube, Roblox (ORG) TikTok (ORG) Hollywood (LOCATION) Silicon Valley (LOCATION) Disney (ORG) John Lasseter (PERSON) Pete Docter (PERSON) Toy Story (ORG) Netflix (ORG) Backrooms (ORG) YouTube (ORG) Minecraft (ORG)
Originally published by The Atlantic Read original →