Politics
Andy Burnham would be 'crazy' not to look for closer ties with the EU
Key Points
Andy Burnham would be 'crazy' not to look for closer ties with the EU EXCLUSIVE: Alan Johnson, who launched Labour’s 2016 campaign to remain in Europe, calls for closer ties with the EU but cautions against a second referendum Andy Burnham has been urged to continue his push for closer EU ties - but not spend political capital on a second referendum. Alan Johnson, who launched Labour’s 2016 campaign to remain in Europe, said: "Europe is still the biggest commercial market in the world —...
Andy Burnham would be 'crazy' not to look for closer ties with the EU
EXCLUSIVE: Alan Johnson, who launched Labour’s 2016 campaign to remain in Europe, calls for closer ties with the EU but cautions against a second referendum
Andy Burnham has been urged to continue his push for closer EU ties - but not spend political capital on a second referendum.
Alan Johnson, who launched Labour’s 2016 campaign to remain in Europe, said: "Europe is still the biggest commercial market in the world — bigger than China, bigger than America. Right on our doorstep, we would be crazy not to look for closer ties. Particularly as the deal that Johnson did was so awful.”
But the ex-Cabinet minister cautioned against another vote on membership of the bloc, warning the Prime Minister’s time would become totally “devoted to this one single issue”. Mr Johnson told The Mirror: “What I don’t want to see is another referendum.”
Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband on Saturday said the Government will consider the potential for the UK to rejoin the EU, saying “of course all the options will be on the table” when asked about rejoining the bloc. "We will look at the benefits and the costs of all the different options," he told BBC’s Laura Kuenssberg.
Referring to Mr Burnham’s comments last month that he would like to see the UK rejoin the EU in his lifetime, Mr Johnson added: “Well his lifetime is going to be longer than my lifetime because he’s a generation younger, but no time soon.
“I'm kind of in favour of closer ties, but against membership because I cannot see how you can go back into Europe without another referendum, and that it would be very damaging.”
Mr Johnson pointed to government priorities, including tackling youth unemployment in the wake of the review by Alan Milburn, and said of the prospect of another EU referendum: “Andy would be best to just leave that alone.”
The Labour grandee suggested Britain could instead push for closer security ties and look to the relationships of other European countries including Switzerland, which has access to the bloc’s single market, but are not members of the European Union.
He said: “If you were going into the single market, it wouldn't require a referendum. Only membership of the European Union would require [one].”
Mr Burnham reopened the debate over Brexit in his first Labour conference speech as PM in September, promising to set out options for the UK’s long-term relationship with Brussels. He suggested it would come around the time of the UK-EU summit, but it is now expected around the time of his 10-year plan for the country, which is due before Christmas.
Friday's summit in Brussels saw the PM agree deals with the EU on food and drink trade, carbon emissions and a reciprocal youth mobility scheme allowing 100,000 young Europeans a year to work and study in the UK. Discussions on the level of tuition fees EU students pay will continue for another six months.
Mr Burnham also promised the EU he's ready to “brainstorm” ideas for closer ties over the next year. The PM has vowed to stick to Labour's 2024 manifesto red lines on not rejoining the EU, single market, or customs union, before the next general election. But he has left the door open to how the UK pushes for closer ties in Labour's next election blueprint document.
It has led to a series of pro-rejoin interventions from a string of Starmer-era Cabinet ministers including former Chancellor Rachel Reeves, ex-Deputy PM David Lammy, and former Business Secretary Peter Kyle.
Earlier this week, Mr Lammy, who was also Foreign Secretary, said Labour should go into the next general election “clear that its intention is to rejoin the EU” in its manifesto. Mr Lammy said once a new deal is agreed with the bloc after post-election negotiations, it should be put to voters in a second referendum on EU membership.
Writing for the Sunday Mirror, Emily Thornberry, chair of the Commons' foreign affairs committee, said she believes Britain "should simply be back in the European Union". "Personally, I think Labour should just be bold, set out exactly what sort of re-entry deal it would seek to secure for the country, slap it on our next manifesto, and let the voters make the final call," she said.
Mr Johnson, the former chair of Labour’s referendum Remain campaign, praised the Prime Minister’s “brave” conference speech to the party faithful. He said: “It was actually saying ‘here’s things we could never talk about, but we should talk about, and we should discuss.’ So let's have the discussion, let's have the conversation. My position is closer ties, but forget about rejoining.”
The former Home Secretary added: “I'm very much in favour of closer ties with Europe. But I can't see how you could put membership of the European Union forward without having another referendum.
“So apart from all the problems you've got, could we still stay out of the single currency? Could we still stay out of Schengen? We lost all those advantages that were negotiated when we were in. Well, they're all gone now.
“And you start mixing those in and you might see that quite soft lead in terms of people saying we should be members of the European Union again— you'll see that vanish.
“Worst of all, you're going to use time and energy and political capital which we should be using to get kids back you know, on the Milburn report and on all the other things. It would totally be devoted to this one single issue.”
The ex-Labour minister also dismissed a recent intervention from failed ex-Tory PM Boris Johnson, who accused Mr Burnham of betraying voters on the issue of Brexit.
But he said: “It’s typical Boris Johnson. He messed this up completely. I mean, you go to people in Northern Ireland where he was promising no border in the Irish Sea — you know, Johnson was completely out of his depth.”
Mr Johnson added: “He's trying to justify a terrible deal. I think we're well beyond thinking that Boris Johnson's got any wisdom in this area.”