Sport
QB rankings for all 68 Power 4 college football teams
Key Points
It has been a particularly strange college football season for the quarterback position. Everyone's top two NFL draft prospects in a seemingly loaded class have either been terribly inconsistent (Texas' Arch Manning) or lost to injury (Oregon's Dante Moore). It's not just Moore, either.
It has been a particularly strange college football season for the quarterback position. Everyone's top two NFL draft prospects in a seemingly loaded class have either been terribly inconsistent (Texas' Arch Manning) or lost to injury (Oregon's Dante Moore).
It's not just Moore, either. Four of the top 20 players from when I ranked power conference QBs in late September have suffered long-term injuries. Mississippi State's Kamario Taylor was the proverbial September Heisman winner; he's out. Ohio State's Julian Sayin and Kansas State's Avery Johnson? Out, too. Florida's Aaron Philo and Indiana's Josh Hoover were each in the top 20 in September; they've struggled and been in and out of the lineup. Stars such as Trinidad Chambliss and Jayden Maiava have neither gotten the help they needed nor delivered on previous seasons' promise.
The result of all this tumult? A very different looking set of rankings. Looking primarily at the last eight weeks or so (all header stats below are from that time period), let's set out to once again list your power conference QBs from the unexpected best to the disappointing worst.
1. Gio Lopez, Wake Forest Demon Deacons
September ranking: 27th Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 91.3 Pass Yds: 1,490 (9.1 yds/db) Rush Yds: 317 (6.5 yds/rush) Total TDs: 18
I like being able to make semi-accurate predictions, but there's nothing better than being completely surprised. And watching Lopez become the best quarterback in college football -- and watching Wake Forest become damn near the best team -- over the last two months has been the best kind of surprise. Since the Demon Deacons' loss to Miami in Week 3, Lopez has thrown for 1,490 yards with a 68% completion rate, 12 TDs, no interceptions and a Total QBR of 91.3. He has also run for 317 non-sack yards and six more scores, and Wake has averaged an eye-popping 44.3 PPG in the process. Hell, Wake has won its past five games by an average of 47-8. 47-8!
If you haven't been watching this team, you've missed out. Lopez should get a revenge attempt against Darian Mensah and Miami in Charlotte in a few weeks, and it wouldn't be a surprise if they won. I have no idea how long this level of form might last, but I also never thought this form could come together in the first place.
2. Darian Mensah, Miami Hurricanes
September ranking: first Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 85.7 Pass Yds: 2,203 (8.6 yds/db) Rush Yds: 176 (7.3 yds/rush) Total TDs: 20
Your job is admittedly pretty easy when you have Malachi Toney to throw to, but Mensah has proved himself in two different ways in 2026. First, his numbers when Toney was healthy weren't only good; they were nearly perfect. He completed 81% of his passes in his first nine starts as a Hurricane, at one point completing 35 straight. And when Toney was sidelined with a high ankle sprain, he struggled for a half before nearly leading Miami back from 21 down against Notre Dame. He then torched Duke, his former team, last week.
Because of Mensah, the Miami offense will be a handful in the CFP even if Toney isn't available or 100%. But it might be the best unit in the playoff if Toney is at full strength.
3. CJ Carr, Notre Dame Fighting Irish
September ranking: second Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 82.3 Pass Yds: 1,659 (7.5 yds/db) Rush Yds: 88 (3.8 yds/rush) Total TDs: 19
With a huge 319-yard, three-touchdown performance against Miami two weeks ago, Carr checked basically the last remaining box for his two years as starter: winning a huge game. We already knew that he was capable of absurd efficiency and a total lack of negative plays -- he has thrown just two interceptions and taken three sacks this season, less than what Texas' Arch Manning and LSU's Sam Leavitt each suffered last Saturday alone. But in outdueling Mensah and keeping the Irish's playoff ranking where it should be, he proved ready for the CFP, where more huge games await.
4. Gunner Stockton, Georgia Bulldogs
September ranking: eighth Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 80.5 Pass Yds: 1,526 (7.9 yds/db) Rush Yds: 183 (4.6 yds/rush) Total TDs: 15
Seemingly every time I wrote about Georgia this past offseason, I mentioned the Bulldogs' lack of explosiveness and how much of a difference it could make if Stockton were to look downfield a bit more (and, obviously, make at least decent passes downfield as well). Well, he's gone from averaging 10.8 yards per completion and 6.7 yards per dropback to 13.4 and 9.6, respectively, and through 10 games Georgia has comfortably been the best team in the country. The Dawgs have won enough blowouts that he hasn't had a ton to do this year from a volume standpoint, but he's produced a Total QBR over 94 in five of 10 games. The extra aggression has looked excellent on him, but he's also still completing 71% of his passes, and he's happy to throw his body around in the red zone as well.
5. Devon Dampier, Utah Utes
September ranking: 10th Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 76.4 Pass Yds: 1,567 (7.3 yds/db) Rush Yds: 524 (6.8 yds/rush) Total TDs: 22
In the lpst four weeks alone, Dampier has outdueled the QBs ranked seventh, ninth and 17th on this list. He's more selective with his legs than he was when he rushed for 1,182 non-sack yards at New Mexico in 2024, but he still topped 100 yards in Utah's tight wins over Houston, BYU and Arizona. And when he needs to make a big pass play, he makes it -- like the game-winning 70-yard strike to Creed Whittemore against Arizona. Both he and his Utes are fearless.
6. Drew Mestemaker, Oklahoma State Cowboys
September ranking: ninth Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 76.0 Pass Yds: 2,357 (9.2 yds/db) Rush Yds: 119 (5.0 yds/rush) Total TDs: 25
There have been a couple of duds along the way -- including last Saturday's disappointing home loss to Texas Tech -- but Mestemaker has lived up to most of the hype he generated in moving from North Texas to OSU with head coach Eric Morris. With 3,239 passing yards and 30 TDs already, he could potentially end up with 4,000 and close to 40, respectively, if he plays in the Cowboys' bowl game. His selectively brilliant running will likely come in handy in the pros, too.
7. Conner Weigman, Houston Cougars
September ranking: 11th Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 84.6 Pass Yds: 1,844 (7.9 yds/db) Rush Yds: 269 (5.5 yds/rush) Total TDs: 24
Houston ranks first nationally in success rate*, second in yards per drive and sixth in points per drive. Weigman seemed like a blue-chip disappointment when he left Texas A&M a couple of seasons ago, but he found a perfect home for his talents, and even though the Cougars couldn't quite maintain a CFP push, he's finishing his career in fantastic form.
(Success rate: how frequently an offense is gaining 50% of necessary yardage on first down, 70% on second and 100% on third and fourth.)
8. Keelon Russell, Alabama Crimson Tide
September ranking: 15th Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 84.2 Pass Yds: 1,716 (7.5 yds/db) Rush Yds: 270 (7.3 yds/rush) Total TDs: 20
He takes too many sacks and runs himself into pressure at times, and four of his six interceptions this season have come in the past four games. Against Vanderbilt last Saturday, he was limited significantly by an ankle injury, and the game was in doubt longer than expected.
Oh yeah, and he can throw the ball a mile and break off a huge run at any point, and his raw upside makes Alabama a national title contender even with the negative plays. (Also, only six INTs for a redshirt freshman is great!)
9. Noah Fifita, Arizona Wildcats
September ranking: 13th Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 79.8 Pass Yds: 2,316 (8.0 yds/db) Rush Yds: 182 (4.5 yds/rush) Total TDs: 19
Fifita remained loyal to Arizona through ups and downs, and he's going to finish his career with something like 13,000 passing yards and 105 touchdowns. He's put together maybe his best campaign yet as a senior, too, even if he couldn't get the Wildcats over the hump against the Big 12's three best teams: Arizona lost to BYU, Texas Tech and Utah by a combined 20 points.
10. LaNorris Sellers, South Carolina Gamecocks
September ranking: 49th Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 80.7 Pass Yds: 1,452 (7.3 yds/db) Rush Yds: 522 (7.7 yds/rush) Total TDs: 18
Sellers' up-and-down career was enjoying one last upward charge before he missed Saturday's loss to Arkansas with injury. The ensuing loss ended the Gamecocks' CFP climb, but that wasn't on Sellers. In his past four starts, he's averaged 260.3 passing yards and 74.5 non-sack rushing yards per game and produced an 86.9 Total QBR. He also gave us this all-time highlight on an injured ankle.
If he's healthy again this Saturday -- signs seem at least semi-optimistic -- he could be a handful even for mighty Georgia.
11. Trinidad Chambliss, Ole Miss Rebels
September ranking: fourth Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 80.4 Pass Yds: 1,562 (6.0 yds/db) Rush Yds: 266 (7.0 yds/rush) Total TDs: 17
It feels strange dropping Chambliss considering how the circumstances have conspired against him this season: Star running back Kewan Lacy has only played in six games, and the defense has allowed 38 PPG in four losses. But in the Rebels' past three losses, including Sunday's rainy defeat in Norman, he completed just 50% of his passes at 9.6 yards per completion (and 4.4 yards per dropback) with three TDs to four INTs. Those are dire numbers even adjusting for difficulty.
12. Michael Hawkins Jr., West Virginia Mountaineers
September ranking: 12th Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 74.2 Pass Yds: 1,651 (8.1 yds/db) Rush Yds: 745 (5.2 yds/rush) Total TDs: 22
The magic might have run out, if last Saturday's dud of a loss against Kansas is any indication, but let's take a moment to celebrate the numbers Hawkins has put up to date. He has thrown for 2,128 yards and rushed for 1,080 non-sack yards so far, and if the Mountaineers reach a bowl -- despite a defense that has allowed at least 37 points in five losses (and at least 27 in two wins) -- he could end up with 2,700 and 1,400 respectively. It's amazing what happens when a QB finds his perfect offense.
13. Thomas Castellanos, Texas Tech Red Raiders
September ranking: NR Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 74.0 Pass Yds: 806 (8.9 yds/db) Rush Yds: 353 (6.4 yds/rush) Total TDs: 13
At both Boston College and Florida State, Castellanos put in brilliant September performances before opponents solved the puzzle, penned him in the pocket and limited his effectiveness from that point forward. After the latest court ruling in his favor, Castellanos has taken over the Tech starting job and maybe saved the Red Raiders' CFP campaign. It's September in November!
Against West Virginia and Oklahoma State, Castellanos threw for 625 yards, nine touchdowns and no interceptions and gained 174 non-sack rushing yards. Tech scored 105 combined points. We don't know how long this form will last -- and I've probably dropped him a couple of spots, fairly or unfairly, because of previous Octobers and Novembers. But as long as he's playing like this, he's one of the best in the sport.
14. Sam Leavitt, LSU Tigers
September ranking: 18th Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 85.2 Pass Yds: 2,065 (7.6 yds/db) Rush Yds: 217 (4.6 yds/rush) Total TDs: 18
Take out the red zone, and Leavitt might be a top-five quarterback. Even despite devastating red zone interceptions -- which prompted losses to Alabama and Texas and ended LSU's CFP hopes -- he still ranks eighth in Total QBR, with high-level efficiency and strong running. But it is hard to forget those picks.
15. Jayden Maiava, USC Trojans
September ranking: sixth Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 79.0 Pass Yds: 1,662 (6.7 yds/db) Rush Yds: 22 (3.1 yds/rush) Total TDs: 10
In USC's past four games, Maiava has enjoyed two brilliant performances in wins over Penn State and Ohio State (four TDs, zero INTs and a 93.8 Total QBR) and two poor performances in losses to Wisconsin and Indiana (two TDs, five INTs and a 65.5 Total QBR). His body of work is still strong enough to rank him this high, but the offense didn't do nearly enough in the losses that ended USC's CFP hopes.
16. Dylan Raiola, Oregon Ducks
September ranking: 21st Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 71.8 Pass Yds: 1,571 (7.3 yds/db) Rush Yds: 23 (2.6 yds/rush) Total TDs: 12
In his first four outings in 2026, including the USC game he saved when Dante Moore got hurt, Raiola produced Total QBR ratings of 98.6, 3.6, 82.9 and 18.0, respectively -- maddening inconsistency even by his own inconsistent standards. But in the past three games, all wins, he has thrown for 934 yards, nine TDs and no interceptions with an 86.1 Total QBR; the Ducks have averaged 35.3 points in this span and played their way back toward CFP contention. So ... is he just awesome now? Is there another down note coming?
17. Bear Bachmeier, BYU Cougars
September ranking: 15th Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 78.9 Pass Yds: 1,484 (6.9 yds/db) Rush Yds: 402 (4.6 yds/rush) Total TDs: 16
Bachmeier's performance has taken a downward turn since the big win over Notre Dame on Oct. 17. In his past four starts, he has completed just 58% of his passes (it was 66% during BYU's 6-0 start) at 7.0 yards per dropback (was 8.1) with a 5.0% interception rate (was 1.3%) and a 74.5 Total QBR (was 82.4). BYU lost two of three before an easy win over Baylor this week, and the Cougars' playoff hopes could hinge on Bachmeier raising his game a bit more in the coming two weeks.
18. Kevin Jennings, SMU Mustangs
September ranking: 11th Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 71.5 Pass Yds: 1,984 (7.5 yds/db) Rush Yds: 199 (5.5 yds/rush) Total TDs: 19
Jennings should finish his career with more than 11,000 passing yards, close to 90 touchdowns, a bunch of wins and a CFP berth. He has pretty consistently been about the 15th- to 20th-best QB in college football. It looked like he and the Mustangs might have a higher ceiling in 2026, but losses to Syracuse and Wake Forest in the past three weeks featured his lowest and third-lowest yards per dropback averages of the season, and the 49-7 loss to Wake ended any remaining CFP hopes.
19. Grant Wilson, Indiana Hoosiers
September ranking: NR Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 73.0 Pass Yds: 474 (9.1 yds/db) Rush Yds: 36 (5.1 yds/rush) Total TDs: 3
This one could turn out to be either too low or far too high, but Wilson, a seventh-year journeyman with stops at Fordham and Old Dominion, filled in for an ailing and/or ineffective Josh Hoover and saved the Hoosiers against Minnesota in Week 9. Then, in his first IU start, he outdueled USC's Jayden Maiava in a 27-13 win. As with Texas Tech's Thomas Castellanos, we're reacting to a tiny sample here, but so far, so good for the unexpected Wilson era.
20. Ty Dieffenbach, UCLA Bruins
September ranking: NR Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 74.3 Pass Yds: 1,218 (8.0 yds/db) Rush Yds: 104 (4.3 yds/rush) Total TDs: 9
UCLA started the season 8-0 thanks to a hyperaggressive defense and a sturdy run game, but the Bruins have suddenly uncovered a new and potentially devastating weapon in November: Dieffenbach going deep to Aidan Mizell. The passing game was mostly limited to quick, semi-successful passes after Dieffenbach took over for injured Nico Iamaleava. But in his past two games, Dieffenbach is 21-for-36 for 535 yards (25.5 per completion!), five TDs and two INTs, and Mizell has eight catches for 326 yards and three of those scores. Perhaps not surprisingly, the Bruins are now 10-0.
21. Aidan Chiles / Nicco Marchiol, Northwestern Wildcats
September ranking: 26th Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 78.8 Pass Yds: 1,790 (6.7 yds/db) Rush Yds: 452 (5.9 yds/rush) Total TDs: 19
Chiles and Northwestern offensive coordinator Chip Kelly were among the sport's main characters in October and inspired this really fun piece, but since the piece came out, the Wildcats lost to Oregon and Chiles missed two games because of injury. Marchiol has been OK, but Chiles would have been in the top 15 if I'd made this list in mid-October.
22. Lincoln Kienholz, Louisville Cardinals
September ranking: 10th Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 68.3 Pass Yds: 1,614 (7.6 yds/db) Rush Yds: 346 (6.5 yds/rush) Total TDs: 16
It's certainly not uncommon for a first-year starter to be inconsistent, but Kienholz has seen some extremes this season: He has produced four starts with a Total QBR over 80 and three at 55 or lower, including Saturday's 40.6 in a rock-fight win over North Carolina. The big plays have definitely trailed off over time -- in three games since completing five passes over 25 yards but throwing two interceptions in a win over Syracuse, Kienholz has averaged a paltry 9.8 yards per completion but hasn't thrown any picks either.
23. Isaiah Marshall, Kansas Jayhawks
September ranking: 62nd Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 74.3 Pass Yds: 1,219 (7.3 yds/db) Rush Yds: 605 (8.2 yds/rush) Total TDs: 11
It's probably too late to save Kansas' hopes of bowl eligibility, but since missing a game because of injury, Marshall has been outstanding in two November starts, completing 72% of his (mostly short) passes and rushing for a combined 292 non-sack yards. His athleticism has never been in question, but with his sudden accuracy, KU has scored 69 points in two weeks.
24. Billy Edwards Jr., North Carolina Tar Heels
September ranking: 63rd Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 73.9 Pass Yds: 1,636 (6.7 yds/db) Rush Yds: 99 (5.0 yds/rush) Total TDs: 15
Until Saturday, Edwards was leading a late-season offensive renaissance -- relatively speaking, at least. UNC averaged 31.8 points in a four-week run that included two wins and a near-upset of Miami, but he was poor against Louisville and then left the game because of injury in the third quarter. He's evidently day-to-day, so I won't worry about including backup Travis Burgess here, but if Edwards is out, UNC's odds of grabbing a sixth win diminish.
25. Ashton Daniels, Florida State Seminoles
September ranking: 34th Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 74.3 Pass Yds: 1,605 (7.4 yds/db) Rush Yds: 447 (7.5 yds/rush) Total TDs: 19
Daniels has been a fun risk taker this season, willing to risk interceptions (12 in total, eight in five losses) for big-play potential (at least 15 yards per completion in five games). Up to 2,309 passing yards, Daniels has been more conservative since star receiver Duce Robinson went down, but he still has a shot at 3,000 passing yards, and the defense, which allowed an average of 40 points in five losses, was the bigger culprit in coach Mike Norvell's firing.
26. Anthony Colandrea, Nebraska Cornhuskers
September ranking: 22nd Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 63.1 Pass Yds: 1,605 (6.0 yds/db) Rush Yds: 478 (8.0 yds/rush) Total TDs: 13
The Virginia and UNLV transfer remains fun and fearless, and with 2,297 passing yards and 579 non-sack rushing yards, he should finish with close to 3,000 and 750, respectively. But he hasn't been able to head off Nebraska's yearslong problems in close games; the Huskers are 0-3 in one-score finishes, and it has turned a potential breakthrough season into something far less.
27. Austin Simmons, Missouri Tigers
September ranking: 30th Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 68.1 Pass Yds: 1,727 (6.8 yds/db) Rush Yds: 49 (3.8 yds/rush) Total TDs: 13
Simmons' draft stock continues to rise despite his announced re-signing for Mizzou for 2027 and despite what remains a drastically up-and-down season as starter. Recent weeks have provided more downs than ups. After averaging 8.7 yards per dropback with 13 TDs and no interceptions during Mizzou's 4-1 start, Simmons has averaged just 6.1 yards per dropback with three picks, and the Tigers have lost three of five. He has a big arm and great anticipation when he's in a rhythm, but rhythm has been harder to find of late.
28. Jaylen Raynor, Iowa State Cyclones
September ranking: 47th Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 67.7 Pass Yds: 1,467 (6.6 yds/db) Rush Yds: 220 (4.1 yds/rush) Total TDs: 12
ISU has averaged 41.0 points over its past three games, and though star running back Aiden Flora has been a big reason for that, the Cyclones' offense has been nicely balanced because of a similar surge from Raynor: He has produced a 79.0 Total QBR and averaged 14.7 yards per completion in this span. It's a benevolent cycle -- big run plays open up big pass plays, which open up big run plays, and so on.
29. Walker Eget, Duke Blue Devils
September ranking: 58th Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 69.3 Pass Yds: 1,505 (6.9 yds/db) Rush Yds: 3 (1.0 yds/rush) Total TDs: 7
For all of Nate Sheppard's amazing exploits this season, the star running back also has had more help from his passing game of late. (Granted, he has been catching plenty of those passes.) Eget has produced a 73.0 Total QBR over his past three games, lowering his yards per dropback average but raising his completion rate and general efficiency. The improvement didn't come until after a couple of losses all but knocked the Blue Devils from the ACC title race, but they're awfully good at the moment.
30. Davis Warren, Stanford Cardinal
September ranking: 37th Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 66.3 Pass Yds: 1,731 (6.9 yds/db) Rush Yds: 74 (7.4 yds/rush) Total TDs: 13
Stanford began the season 2-4, averaging a dreadful 5.8 points in the losses. But the Cardinal have won three of their past four, averaging 32.3 points in the process, and though running back Micah Ford has erupted in this period, Warren's improved efficiency and sack avoidance have also had roles to play. Stanford is one win away from a bowl bid no one really saw coming.
31. Kenny Minchey, Kentucky Wildcats
September ranking: 55th Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 65.1 Pass Yds: 1,461 (5.8 yds/db) Rush Yds: 156 (5.0 yds/rush) Total TDs: 11
Minchey has basically experienced three different seasons this fall. September brought two buy-game blowouts, a great performance against Texas A&M, a total dud against Alabama and a 3-1 record. October brought four wins, a 79.2 Total QBR and a top-10 CFP ranking. And November has brought two demoralizing losses, 20 total points and a 52.6 Total QBR. Minchey has averaged only 10.7 yards per completion against SEC opponents, and a lack of explosiveness will usually catch up to you. It did so with Minchey the moment November began.
32. Hank Brown, Iowa Hawkeyes
September ranking: 39th Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 67.2 Pass Yds: 1,031 (5.8 yds/db) Rush Yds: 108 (6.0 yds/rush) Total TDs: 9
Since briefly losing his job to Jeremy Hecklinski, Brown has returned to the lineup and thrived. In his past three starts (which includes games against solid Wisconsin and Northwestern defenses), he has produced an 84.2 Total QBR with high-level efficiency (75.7% completion rate), steady run production and only one interception. Big plays are minimal, but for a strong rushing-and-defense team, Brown is keeping things steady.
33. Katin Houser, Illinois Fighting Illini
September ranking: 16th Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 65.9 Pass Yds: 1,373 (6.2 yds/db) Rush Yds: 145 (5.6 yds/rush) Total TDs: 11
It's hard to evaluate Houser. He rushed back from a hand injury (a la John Mateer last season) and earned major toughness and leadership points, but he also has averaged just 6.2 yards per dropback with four interceptions and a 59.6 Total QBR in three games since his return, and Illinois has averaged just 19.3 points. He also sustained a broken nose and a concussion on the final drive of last week's loss to UCLA; with backup Michael Clayton II also out, third-stringer Carson Boyd could be this week's starter if Houser can't go. Boyd has completed one pass this season.
34. John Mateer, Oklahoma Sooners
September ranking: 48th Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 62.8 Pass Yds: 1,501 (5.8 yds/db) Rush Yds: 300 (4.2 yds/rush) Total TDs: 10
We've seen a spark from Mateer over the past month. It didn't come quickly enough to save offensive coordinator Ben Arbuckle's job (or OU's season), but in his past four games, he has produced a 73.6 Total QBR, zero interceptions, higher quality rushing and three wins. And after averaging 15.8 points in the first four games against power-conference opponents, the Sooners have averaged 23.8 in the past four. Great? No way. Decent? Absolutely.
35. Arch Manning, Texas Longhorns
September ranking: 29th Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 60.8 Pass Yds: 1,537 (6.3 yds/db) Rush Yds: 225 (5.6 yds/rush) Total TDs: 15
Manning remains one of the most impossible guys to evaluate. He engineered incredible, late go-ahead drives against Ohio State and LSU, and Texas probably will be in the CFP because of it. But the Longhorns' CFP status was thrown into doubt for quite a while, in part because of how awful he was late in losses to Oklahoma and Florida (and in a near-loss to Ole Miss). And he threw three picks and took four sacks before the winning drive against LSU. Two years into the Manning experience, he's as maddeningly inconsistent as ever.
36. CJ Bailey, NC State Wolfpack
September ranking: 41st Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 68.5 Pass Yds: 1,649 (6.7 yds/db) Rush Yds: 225 (6.1 yds/rush) Total TDs: 12
On paper, Bailey has been pretty solid since a dreadful Week 0 dud against Virginia. But his season will be defined by crippling mistakes such as the apocalyptic fumble against Vanderbilt and an interception that allowed Syracuse to take a late lead last week. This is a pretty unfair sport sometimes.
37. Byrum Brown, Auburn Tigers
September ranking: 35th Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 66.2 Pass Yds: 1,216 (5.0 yds/db) Rush Yds: 593 (5.9 yds/rush) Total TDs: 16
I expected a lot from Brown this season, but while he has remained a strong threat with his legs, he has been too inconsistent with his arm. Still, he has dramatically cut down the interceptions over the past five games, and Auburn is 2-0 in November (albeit against Arkansas and Mississippi State).
38. DJ Lagway, Baylor Bears
September ranking: 52nd Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 64.7 Pass Yds: 1,726 (6.1 yds/db) Rush Yds: 319 (7.6 yds/rush) Total TDs: 16
Either it all works or it all doesn't for Lagway. In eight starts, he's 4-4. In four wins, he has produced a 77.8 Total QBR, averaged 7.5 yards per dropback and produced a 12-to-1 TD-to-INT ratio, and Baylor has averaged 40.3 points. In four losses: 46.9 Total QBR, 5.0 yards per dropback, 4-to-4 TDs-to-INTs and 13.3 PPG. He remains a huge roll of the dice.
39. Rocco Becht, Penn State Nittany Lions
September ranking: 40th Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 63.8 Pass Yds: 1,412 (5.8 yds/db) Rush Yds: 179 (3.5 yds/rush) Total TDs: 12
Becht hit his head on a pretty clear ceiling during Penn State's four-game losing streak, but in the three wins that have followed, the Nittany Lions have averaged 33.7 points, and Becht has gotten out of the way, throwing six touchdowns with no picks. He basically has spent his entire career with a Total QBR in the 60s, and that's where he's finishing it -- he's the ultimate "You could do better, but you could also do worse" guy.
40. Alonza Barnett III / Keyone Jenkins, UCF Knights
September ranking: 59th Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 58.7 Pass Yds: 1,694 (6.1 yds/db) Rush Yds: 139 (3.3 yds/rush) Total TDs: 14
Here's another one from the "could do better, could do worse" department: After sitting out nearly two months because of a hamstring injury, Barnett returned to the lineup two weeks ago and has since produced a strong start (33-32 win over Kansas) and a poor one (26-13 loss to Arizona State). Barnett and Jenkins have basically produced the same numbers and the same up-and-down play.
41. Jaden Craig, TCU Horned Frogs
September ranking: 46th Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 59.0 Pass Yds: 1,761 (5.8 yds/db) Rush Yds: 214 (5.2 yds/rush) Total TDs: 10
Craig has been consistently inconsistent in his lone season of FBS ball, averaging between 5.0 and 7.0 yards per dropback in six of his past seven starts with a Total QBR between 52 and 74 in seven of his past nine. But TCU has topped 20 points only four times this season and is 5-5 despite a strong defense.
42. KJ Jackson, Arkansas Razorbacks
September ranking: 65th Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 62.4 Pass Yds: 1,423 (6.0 yds/db) Rush Yds: 238 (4.3 yds/rush) Total TDs: 10
Sometimes you have to squint to see progress, but since Arkansas' season-low point, a 34-7 loss at Texas A&M, Jackson and the Razorbacks have figured out how to become more competitive. In his past five starts, Jackson has cut his interception rate, made a few more big plays, generated a decent 65.4 Total QBR and led the Hogs to a pair of conference wins. None of this is awe-inspiring, but it's still improvement.
43. Luke Fahey, Ohio State Buckeyes
September ranking: NR Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 52.6 Pass Yds: 821 (6.0 yds/db) Rush Yds: 62 (5.2 yds/rush) Total TDs: 6
As far as freshmen go, Fahey has gotten up to speed pretty quickly in his three starts since taking over for injured Julian Sayin (who ranked third on this list in September). He has completed 65% of his passes with six touchdowns to only two interceptions, and the Buckeyes have scored 28 points in each of the past two weeks. Still, by the standard of Ohio State quarterbacks, he's not hitting the notes just yet.
44. Demond Williams Jr., Washington Huskies
September ranking: 31st Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 56.3 Pass Yds: 1,065 (6.0 yds/db) Rush Yds: 232 (6.4 yds/rush) Total TDs: 9
Williams has been in and out of the lineup because of a rib injury, but he has produced a 77.5 Total QBR, and Washington has won two of three, since he returned to spark a late rally against Nebraska. That clinched a bowl game, at least.
45. JC French IV, Cincinnati Bearcats
September ranking: 36th Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 47.4 Pass Yds: 1,456 (6.9 yds/db) Rush Yds: 285 (4.8 yds/rush) Total TDs: 15
He torched Kansas State and West Virginia, and played pretty well in an upset of Texas Tech. He also did next to nothing against Arizona and Iowa State, and his sack rate has been creeping up for a while. It has been a hit-and-miss season for the Georgia Southern transfer, and with five losses in six games, it's not ending incredibly well.
46. Ryan Browne, Purdue Boilermakers
September ranking: 32nd Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 62.4 Pass Yds: 1,394 (6.0 yds/db) Rush Yds: 210 (6.6 yds/rush) Total TDs: 7
In his first six starts, Browne led Purdue to an encouraging 3-3 record with four games over 35 points, an 83.2 Total QBR and a solid 7.8 yards per dropback with one interception. It was a fun comeback story for the veteran. The past four games have been a different story: 54.0 Total QBR, 5.8 yards per dropback, five INTs, four losses and 19.8 PPG.
47. Ethan Grunkemeyer, Virginia Tech Hokies
September ranking: 25th Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 54.6 Pass Yds: 1,836 (6.4 yds/db) Rush Yds: 181 (4.3 yds/rush) Total TDs: 17
The drop-off has come suddenly for Virginia Tech, which lost to SMU and Stanford by a combined 41 points in the past two weeks. Grunkemeyer, meanwhile, has averaged just 5.2 yards per dropback (4.1 in the first half) with three picks and a 42.0 Total QBR in the past three games. We don't know if this is a blip or a downward spiral, but it's not great regardless.
48. Isaac Wilson, Colorado Buffaloes
September ranking: NR Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 45.6 Pass Yds: 1,632 (7.1 yds/db) Rush Yds: 170 (3.1 yds/rush) Total TDs: 10
The former Utah quarterback nearly led a late upset of the Utes in his second start and has beaten Kansas State and Houston in his past two home starts. CU also has scored at least 24 points in four of its last five games. His numbers aren't incredible, but the Buffaloes have shown random signs of life, especially in Boulder.
49. Steve Angeli, Syracuse Orange
September ranking: 68th Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 52.5 Pass Yds: 991 (6.1 yds/db) Rush Yds: 55 (7.9 yds/rush) Total TDs: 7
The lowest-ranked quarterback on the list in September, Angeli was out of the lineup for a month, but he has led Syracuse to three wins (all with 30 points or more) in four starts since he returned. He still isn't doing amazing, but he has cut down on the picks and raised his efficiency a hair, and he has averaged 9.0 yards per dropback in the fourth quarter of these recent tight wins.
50. Alessio Milivojevic, Michigan State Spartans
September ranking: 57th Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 64.4 Pass Yds: 1,019 (5.5 yds/db) Rush Yds: 58 (4.5 yds/rush) Total TDs: 5
Milivojevic is a Big Ten quarterback, and therefore he has battled injury issues -- an injured shoulder also has rendered him questionable moving forward -- but in his past four starts, he has produced a 71.0 Total QBR and raised his completion rate to 69.0%. He also hasn't thrown a pick since September. If Kayd Coffman (4-for-11 on the season) is the guy moving forward, the ranking drops.
51. Jared Curtis, Vanderbilt Commodores
September ranking: 45th Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 53.8 Pass Yds: 1,333 (5.7 yds/db) Rush Yds: 180 (4.1 yds/rush) Total TDs: 4
Maybe it's a good sign that Curtis, a blue-chip freshman thrown into the fire without a proper supporting cast, has never had a true meltdown game, with three picks or 3.0 yards per dropback or anything. But he also has topped 6.0 yards per dropback only once in SEC play. It hasn't bottomed out, but it also hasn't really gotten better.
52. Aaron Philo / Tramell Jones Jr., Florida Gators
September ranking: 12th Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 59.5 Pass Yds: 1,351 (5.7 yds/db) Rush Yds: 349 (5.9 yds/rush) Total TDs: 9
Rarely does the magic so emphatically disappear. With Philo, Florida averaged 53.5 points and scored 44 or more on both Auburn and Ole Miss. In their past six games, the Gators have averaged 16.5 points. Philo averaged 5.5 yards per dropback against Kentucky, and UF scored 21 points, and it felt miraculous.
53. Tommy Carr, Michigan Wolverines
September ranking: NR Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 59.9 Pass Yds: 663 (5.2 yds/db) Rush Yds: 209 (6.1 yds/rush) Total TDs: 4
Things seemed promising, but that was just the Rutgers effect. Carr torched the Scarlet Knights in his second start, but in two starts since, he has managed a 26.5 Total QBR and 3.8 yards per dropback, and Michigan has scored 13 total points. Bryce Underwood might get his job back soon, but Underwood was just 2-for-8 on Saturday too.
54. Mikey Keene / Jake Fette / Cutter Boley, Arizona State Sun Devils
September ranking: NR Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 48.3 Pass Yds: 1,650 (5.5 yds/db) Rush Yds: 153 (4.8 yds/rush) Total TDs: 9
Boley was demoted following a 53-25 loss to Texas Tech, but the Sun Devils have won three of their past four with first Keene (until he got hurt) and now the freshman Fette. They have averaged only 5.0 yards per dropback in this span, but they haven't thrown any interceptions, and an improving run game and defense have taken it from there.
55. Malik Washington / Cardell Williams, Maryland Terrapins
September ranking: 56th Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 44.9 Pass Yds: 1,349 (5.9 yds/db) Rush Yds: 230 (4.5 yds/rush) Total TDs: 12
It just never worked out for Washington and head coach Mike Locksley, who was fired five games into a six-game losing streak in which Washington averaged just 5.5 yards per dropback with a 39.0 Total QBR. But Washington played well in a win over Purdue, and then backup Williams led the Terrapins to an upset of Wisconsin with Washington out. It will take wins over USC and Penn State to eke out bowl eligibility, but the past couple of weeks have been pleasant, anyway.
56. Beau Pribula, Virginia Cavaliers
September ranking: 24th Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 47.0 Pass Yds: 1,213 (5.5 yds/db) Rush Yds: 293 (5.1 yds/rush) Total TDs: 10
Last season at Missouri, Pribula enjoyed an 82.6 Total QBR in his first four starts (all wins) but managed just a 53.9 from there and went 3-3 in his last six starts. It has been a similar story in Charlottesville: He posted a 77.4 Total QBR during a 3-1 start but has been at just 37.5 as the Cavaliers have lost four of six. A lack of explosiveness eventually catches up to you.
57. Drake Lindsey, Minnesota Golden Gophers
September ranking: 51st Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 41.5 Pass Yds: 1,235 (5.0 yds/db) Rush Yds: 11 (0.9 yds/rush) Total TDs: 9
In September, I wrote that Lindsey was completing 67% of his passes, but the total lack of explosiveness in the passing game would eventually cost the Gophers. Well, they've lost four of their past five and have averaged just 15.2 points, with Lindsey averaging 4.6 yards per dropback, in the process.
58. George MacIntyre, Tennessee Volunteers
September ranking: NR Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 31.4 Pass Yds: 906 (6.4 yds/db) Rush Yds: 23 (2.3 yds/rush) Total TDs: 1
The moment grew too big for freshman Faizon Brandon, so MacIntyre has started the past five games. That the Vols have won four of those five and are still on track for a CFP berth says he has done job No. 1: don't blow it. He has thrown only three picks and taken only eight sacks. But his Total QBR speaks for itself, and his success rate on third and fourth downs is a ghastly 21.7%. If UT can't win via the defense-and-rushing path, it can't win.
59. Alberto Mendoza, Georgia Tech Yellow Jackets
September ranking: 53rd Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 39.2 Pass Yds: 1,374 (6.0 yds/db) Rush Yds: 133 (6.3 yds/rush) Total TDs: 7
I had decent hopes for Mendoza after he shined in a small sample at Indiana, but he hasn't gotten nearly enough help from his line or the run game, and he hasn't risen to the moment. Tech averaged 16.0 points in its past three games.
60. Holden Geriner / Corey Dailey, Pittsburgh Panthers
September ranking: NR Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 33.7 Pass Yds: 1,017 (5.8 yds/db) Rush Yds: 122 (5.3 yds/rush) Total TDs: 4
Mason Heintschel was lost for the season because of injury after a 5-0 start, and Pitt has lost four of five since. Geriner helped to lead the Panthers to a win over Georgia Tech, but he got hurt, and Dailey couldn't steer them to a win over Florida State. The defense is still good, but Heintschel's injury killed the season.
61. Ryan Hopkins / Colton Joseph, Wisconsin Badgers
September ranking: 43 Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 36.8 Pass Yds: 1,027 (5.6 yds/db) Rush Yds: 351 (5.1 yds/rush) Total TDs: 12
I had a lot of hope for Joseph, an Old Dominion transfer, this season, but after an up-and-down start, he has been merely down over his past five games, posting just a 28.7 Total QBR. He was benched for Hopkins, a freshman, and he was good against Rutgers but awful against Maryland and got hurt late. None of this is great.
62. Mason McKenzie, Boston College Eagles
September ranking: 67th Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 43.0 Pass Yds: 1,019 (5.3 yds/db) Rush Yds: 600 (6.5 yds/rush) Total TDs: 11
McKenzie, a Division II transfer, is a scrambler-gambler type who doesn't mind taking some hits and has topped 100 non-sack rushing yards four times. But the passing game has really worked only a couple of times, and he has averaged 3.7 yards per dropback in the past three games (all losses).
63. Dylan Lonergan / AJ Surace / Sean Ashenfelder, Rutgers Scarlet Knights
September ranking: 64th Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 41.2 Pass Yds: 1,180 (5.9 yds/db) Rush Yds: 99 (3.7 yds/rush) Total TDs: 9
Lonergan was in and out of the lineup all season but played well in an upset of Maryland. The next week, he sustained a concussion and has sat out most of the past four games; the Scarlet Knights lost all four and averaged just 11.3 points.
64. Dillon Duff / Blake Barnett, Kansas State Wildcats
September ranking: NR Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 47.2 Pass Yds: 670 (5.6 yds/db) Rush Yds: 127 (4.1 yds/rush) Total TDs: 6
K-State was a decent 4-2 when Avery Johnson got hurt. The Wildcats are 0-4 since. Barnett almost saved the Colorado game on Halloween but fell short, and K-State has lost the other three games by an average of 19.7.
65. Jaron-Keawe Sagapolutele, California Golden Bears
September ranking: 50th Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 33.6 Pass Yds: 1,026 (4.6 yds/db) Rush Yds: 26 (3.3 yds/rush) Total TDs: 4
It was a big deal that JKS returned to be the face of Tosh Lupoi's first Cal squad, but after a semi-promising 2-1 start, the past two months have been horrendous. He has lost five straight starts, and Cal topped 10 points in only two of them.
66. AJ Swann / Parker Puckett, Mississippi State Bulldogs
September ranking: NR Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 30.2 Pass Yds: 884 (4.8 yds/db) Rush Yds: 144 (5.5 yds/rush) Total TDs: 4
Kamario Taylor ranked fifth on my September list and inspired a 4-0 start in Starkville, but he tried to play through a turf toe injury against Alabama, everything got worse, and he has thrown only five passes since. MSU also hasn't won since the 4-0 start. Swann and Puckett have combined to average only 4.8 yards per dropback, and the Bulldogs have averaged 10.0 points in their past five games.
67. Marcel Reed, Texas A&M Aggies
September ranking: 60th Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 34.7 Pass Yds: 1,080 (5.2 yds/db) Rush Yds: 198 (4.6 yds/rush) Total TDs: 4
A&M head coach Mike Elko made a point to try to take as much blame as possible for the Aggies' woeful offense and tried to take some of the heat off of Reed, saying, "I don't know how you can put this on one kid." True, but Reed has had an utterly dismal season. It has been hard to watch.
68. Christopher Vizzina (or Trent Pearman?), Clemson Tigers
September ranking: NR Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 15.4 Pass Yds: 133 (3.6 yds/db) Rush Yds: 40 (6.7 yds/rush) Total TDs: 0
This season hasn't gone as Vizzina hoped. Deemed Cade Klubnik's successor, he struggled mightily to start the season, got hurt, got benched and didn't reappear until Saturday's loss to Georgia Tech, in which he went 12-for-27, hurt his ankle, then sustained a concussion. Fifth-year walk-on Trent Pearman might get snaps this week instead. It can't get worse, but it might not get better.